This study analyses criminal liability for narcotics traffickers under Law Number 35 of 2009, focusing on the evidentiary requirement of intent to distribute. The background stems from the persistent difficulty in distinguishing traffickers from users, which leads to misclassification, sentencing disparities, and excessive criminalisation of personal abuse. The research employs a normative legal method with statutory, conceptual, and case approaches, using primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials analysed qualitatively through descriptive-analytical reasoning. The findings show that criminal liability requires cumulative proof of an unlawful act, fault, and capacity to bear responsibility. However, the Narcotics Law does not clearly differentiate between addicts and dealers, creating interpretive uncertainty. Judicial practice demonstrates that intent to distribute cannot be established solely by quantity of narcotics seized; it must be inferred from totality of evidence, including packaging, communications, financial transactions, and the defendant’s role. Sentencing disparities often arise from differences in legal construction rather than evidentiary weight. Law Number 20 of 2025 introduces stronger procedural safeguards, including recognition of undercover buy techniques, but its effectiveness depends on consistent implementation and clear evidentiary guidelines. The novelty lies in integrating substantive, procedural, and sentencing dimensions to offer a coherent framework linking statutory elements with the new procedural framework. The study recommends strengthening evidentiary mechanisms, investigative capacity, and guidelines for assessing intent to distribute to promote legal certainty, proportionality, and fairness.
Copyrights © 2026