The right to life is a non-derogable right guaranteed by both positive law and Islamic law through the concept of hifz al-nafs. The practice of extrajudicial killing remains a serious issue in Indonesia, as reflected in Decision Number 213 K/Mil/2025 involving three Indonesian Navy (TNI AL) personnel. Previous research has generally examined this issue solely from the perspective of human rights and state accountability, leaving a gap in studies assessing military court decisions through the lens of maqāṣid al-sharīʿah, particularly hifz al-nafs. This normative juridical research analyzes the judges' legal reasoning from the perspective of the right to life and due process of law. The findings indicate that the decision lacks transparency in determining the punishment and restitution, although the restitution granted converges with the principle of hifz al-nafs as a combined implementation of ta'zir and diyat. However, the sentence reduction in this decision was not adequately explained, leading to the conclusion that the decision represents a progressive step that has not yet been optimal in realizing restorative justice oriented toward victim recovery.
Copyrights © 2026