Constitutional Court Decision Number 66/PUU-XXIV/2026 conditionally reinterprets “state loss” in Article 20(5)-(6) of the Government Administration Law into “state financial loss,” narrowing loss-recovery to actual, calculable funds. This article examines that reasoning alongside Decision Number 28/PUU-XXIV/2026, affirming the Supreme Audit Board (BPK) as the exclusive authority determining state financial loss. Using normative legal research with statutory, case, and conceptual approaches, the article argues both decisions strengthen bureaucratic discretion and ultimum remedium, yet leave three unresolved fault lines: overlap between BPK, BPKP, and internal auditors; inconsistency between the materiel-delict standard for corruption and the rigid ten-day period; and absent implementing regulation, perpetuating conceptual confusion between administrative fault and criminal abuse of authority. The article resolves this through doctrinal analysis of the State Administrative Court's gatekeeping role and proposes an original construct, the State Financial Loss Filter Model (SFLM), sequencing four cumulative filters: detection, constitutional verification, mens rea testing, and an ultimum remedium gate, before prosecution may proceed. Comparative analysis shows clearer institutional separation yields more predictable accountability, while law-and-economics analysis shows the SFLM reduces bureaucratic risk-aversion, improving investment climate and public service delivery. The article recommends implementing regulations and a joint technical guideline among the Supreme Court, Attorney General, and BPK.
Copyrights © 2026