Constitutional Court Decision Number 66/PUU-XXIV/2026 reaffirms the boundary between administrative law and criminal corruption law in interpreting the phrases "state loss" and "state financial loss" as regulated in Law Number 30 of 2014 on Government Administration. This research addresses two problem formulations, namely how the boundary of state financial loss is separated between the administrative and criminal domains following the decision, and what direction (quo vadis) its future resolution should take. The research employs a normative(doctrinal) legal method with statute and philosophical approaches, drawing on primary legal materials such as the Constitutional Court decision and related legislation, as well as secondary legal materials from administrative and criminal law literature, analyzed qualitatively. The findings show that the Constitutional Court positions administrative law as the primary instrument (primum remedium) before criminal proceedings may be pursued, affirming mens rea as an essential requirement for criminal liability, while encouraging a paradigm shift from formal to material offense doctrine in proving corruption. Nevertheless, law enforcement practice, particularly by the Prosecutor's Office, still tends to favor criminal prosecution, meaning the decision's success ultimately depends on accompanying institutional reform.
Copyrights © 2026