Constitutional Court (MK) Decision Number 66/PUU-XXIV/2026 (29 April 2026) affirms that "state loss" in Article 20(5)–(6) of Law Number 30 of 2014 on Government Administration is binding only when interpreted as "state financial loss," requiring real, quantifiable loss (actual loss) and positioning administrative mechanisms as primum remedium before criminal enforcement as ultimum remedium. While providing legal certainty, this narrowing risks excluding administrative and functional losses such as disrupted public services and eroded public trust from the prevailing accountability paradigm. This research analyzes the implications of the Decision for public official accountability, examines the Islamic law principle of Hisbah as an accountability concept, and proposes a reconstructed paradigm for state financial loss accountability grounded in Hisbah. Using normative legal research with statute, case, and conceptual approaches, findings show that current accountability remains reactive and loss-based, whereas Hisbah offers a preventive-corrective, trust-based paradigm. The proposed reconstruction integrates amanah (integrity), hifdzu-l mal (protection of public wealth), and mashlaḥah (public benefit) into existing administrative law structures without institutional change, shifting accountability from outcome-based toward trust-based orientation.
Copyrights © 2026