Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search

Legal Uncertainty in Professional Disciplinary Council Recommendations for Patient Civil Claims Under Indonesia's 2023 Health Law Aninditia Widyanti; Arman Anwar; Renny Heronia Nendissa
International Journal of Business, Law, and Education Vol. 7 No. 2 (2026): International Journal of Business, Law, and Education (on progres)
Publisher : IJBLE Scientific Publications Community Inc.

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56442/ijble.v7i2.1565

Abstract

Law Number 17 of 2023 on Health introduced a Professional Disciplinary Council (Majelis Disiplin Profesi, MDP) recommendation mechanism for civil claims arising from medical and health services. Article 308(2) requires a recommendation where medical or health personnel are held civilly liable for conduct that allegedly harms a patient, while Article 308(4) provides that the recommendation is issued after the defendant, or an authorized representative, submits a written request. This study examines whether that procedural design satisfies the requirements of legal certainty, procedural fairness, and effective access to justice. It employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and case approaches. Primary legal materials include Law Number 17 of 2023, Government Regulation Number 28 of 2024, Minister of Health Regulation Number 3 of 2025, and recent Constitutional Court decisions concerning Article 308. The analysis shows that the MDP mechanism has a legitimate protective rationale: professional standards should be assessed by a competent disciplinary body before medical conduct is treated as legal fault. Nevertheless, the allocation of procedural initiative to the defendant, the absence of an express consequence for failure to request a recommendation, and uncertainty regarding the recommendation's effect on judicial examination create a structural risk of inconsistent civil procedure. The article argues that the problem is not the existence of professional review itself, but the incomplete legal architecture governing its relationship with the court. It proposes a court-triggered referral mechanism, a strict time limit, a non-preclusive consequence for defendant inaction, and an explicit rule that MDP recommendations inform but do not bind judicial determinations of civil liability.
Procedural Uncertainty in Professional Disciplinary Council Recommendations for Patient Civil Claims under Indonesia’s Health Law Aninditia Widyanti; Arman Anwar; Renny Heronia Nendissa
PERFECT EDUCATION FAIRY Vol. 4 No. 3 (2026): PERFECT EDUCATION FAIRY (on progres)
Publisher : PT. Batari Edu Calya

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56442/pef.v4i3.1581

Abstract

Law No. 17 of 2023 on Health introduced a mandatory recommendation mechanism of the Professional Disciplinary Council (Majelis Disiplin Profesi, MDP) for civil accountability arising from medical and health services. Article 308(2) requires the recommendation, while Article 308(4) assigns the initiative to request it to the medical or health professional being sued, or that person’s authorized representative. This article examines whether that design provides sufficient procedural certainty and balanced access to adjudication for patients. Using doctrinal legal research, the study analyzes Law No. 17 of 2023, Government Regulation No. 28 of 2024, Minister of Health Regulation No. 3 of 2025, relevant Constitutional Court decisions, selected civil litigation records, and scholarly literature on legal certainty, access to justice, medical dispute resolution, and professional discipline. The analysis shows that the recommendation mechanism has a legitimate protective and epistemic function: it supplies professional assessment of compliance with professional, service, and operational standards. The Constitutional Court has also upheld the constitutionality of Article 308. Nevertheless, an operational asymmetry remains. Patients may file civil claims, but they cannot directly trigger the statutory recommendation; the regulations do not expressly prescribe a civil-law consequence when the defendant does not apply for it; and the deemed-recommendation rule for institutional silence is expressly linked to criminal investigation. This design can generate inconsistent procedural interpretations. The article therefore proposes a clarification model that preserves professional review while preventing the recommendation from functioning as a procedural veto. The contribution of this study is to distinguish constitutional validity from procedural completeness and to identify targeted reforms capable of protecting both healthcare professionals and patients without displacing the authority of civil courts.