Human trafficking is a transnational and multidimensional crime that poses serious challenges to criminal investigation and proof, particularly in the digital era. This study examines the process of proving human trafficking offences, with particular attention to the evidentiary role and admissibility of digital evidence. It employs a normative/doctrinal legal research method, supported by a comparative analysis of Kazakhstan’s legal framework and relevant international legal instruments. The study finds that proving human trafficking requires a combination of conventional investigative measures and digitally mediated evidentiary tools, including electronic records, screen captures, web-based data, and metadata. However, the legal regulation of digital evidence remains fragmented, especially with regard to its classification, admissibility, preservation, and cross-border use in criminal proceedings. The analysis further shows that Kazakhstan’s legal framework provides basic recognition of electronic documents but does not yet offer a sufficiently clear procedural framework for handling digital evidence in trafficking cases. This article contributes to the literature by linking the evidentiary challenges of digital evidence directly to the prosecution of human trafficking offences and by highlighting the need for a more coherent legal framework governing authenticity, integrity, and admissibility. The findings suggest that stronger procedural safeguards, legal reform, and enhanced international cooperation are necessary to improve the effectiveness of trafficking prosecutions.