Purpose – This study examines hadiths prohibiting the solicitation of positions of authority (al-imarah) to construct an integrative interpretation with implications for contemporary Islamic leadership ethics. Design – A systematic thematic (mawdu’i) approach was employed, integrating isnad criticism, matn evaluation, and contextual reconstruction. Using the Hadith Soft application, a targeted search for the keyword al-imarah retrieved thirty-seven narrations from five canonical collections (Sahih al-Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Sunan al-Tirmidhi, Sunan Abu Dawud, and Sunan al-Nasa’i). Fourteen narrations representing independent transmission chains with distinct isnad configurations were analyzed in depth; the remaining narrations served as textual variants. Rijal criticism and matn evaluation were conducted using al-Khatib al-Baghdadi’s and al-Adabi's canonical criteria. Findings – The primary transmission chains are classified as Sahih and marfu’, with all key transmitters rated thiqah. Matn analysis reveals consistency with Quranic principles; the apparent contradiction with Q. Yusuf (12):55 is resolved through harmonization (al-jam’), establishing that the prohibition targets those lacking competence and integrity, while permitting or obligating position-seeking for the qualified. Contextual reconstruction yields a tripartite typology: requesting office is prohibited (haram) when lacking qualifications, recommended (sunnah) when possessing superior qualifications, and obligatory (wajib) when necessary to prevent institutional harm. Research Implications – The findings challenge partial textual readings and provide actionable frameworks for merit-based leadership selection in contemporary Muslim institutions. The study is limited by its dependence on classical rijal assessments and the absence of empirical data on actual institutional practice; future research should address these gaps through field-based or comparative institutional studies. Originality – This study contributes an integrative framework that bridges classical hadith methodology with contemporary Islamic leadership ethics discourse, addressing a notable gap in scholarship on Islamic governance and offering scholars and practitioners a methodologically grounded typology for evaluating the ethics of position-seeking.