The rapid growth of digital financial activities, particularly the emergence of stock influencers, has created new challenges in regulating illegal fundraising practices and protecting investors within the capital market, as illustrated in the case of Ahmad Rafif Raya (ARR). These developments expose regulatory gaps, especially when misconduct is committed by hybrid actors operating outside formal institutional frameworks. This study aims to analyze the limitations of the Financial Services Authority (OJK) in protecting investors and facilitating the recovery of losses in such cases. This study employed a normative-empirical approach, examining statutory regulations, legal doctrines, case analysis, and secondary data including PASTI documents, OJK responses, and academic interviews. The findings revealed a structural gap between OJK’s formal authority and its enforcement capacity in the digital financial ecosystem. Although OJK can order disgorgement, enforcement is limited to regulated entities, excluding grey-area actors like Ahmad Rafif Raya (ARR) and forcing reliance on slower general legal mechanisms. Furthermore, disgorgement fails as a remedy when no unlawful profits are secured. In such situations, investor recovery tends to rely on informal arrangements, such as converting losses into personal debt, which lacks legal certainty and does not eliminate criminal liability. These conditions show the current legal framework has not fully adapted to digital financial risks. This study highlights the need for legal reform to expand disgorgement beyond formal actors, strengthen cross-sector enforcement, and develop adaptive, recovery-oriented mechanisms for effective investor protection.