Divorce within Indonesia's national marriage law is positioned as a last resort deliberately made difficult, in line with the principle of sadd al-dzarī'ah within maqashid al-shari'ah. The persistently high divorce rate at the Ciamis Religious Court between 2024 and 2025 indicates that implementation of this principle faces considerable challenges in practice. This study aims to identify the factors limiting the effectiveness of the principle of complicating divorce and to examine the concrete measures taken by the panel of judges in response. An empirical juridical method with a socio-legal qualitative approach was employed, through an in-depth interview with the Vice Chairman of the Ciamis Religious Court and documentation analysis of mediation reports for 2024–2025. The findings show that judges consistently fulfilled normative indicators of the principle including mandatory mediation, reconciliation efforts at every stage of trial, and strict evidentiary standards yet only seven of 624 mediated cases (1.12%) resulted in full reconciliation, constrained by the disputing parties' psychological condition, limited legal-technological literacy, and institutional workload. This finding indicates that low reconciliation rates should not be equated with failure to implement the principle, since implementation is a judicial obligation within the court's control, whereas reconciliation outcomes depend on the parties' will. This study contributes an indicator-based framework for evaluating the implementation of the principle of complicating divorce, distinct from its effectiveness in preventing divorce, for the study of Islamic family law.