The abolition of Indonesia's National Examination marks a fundamental shift in educational evaluation policy, yet its relationship with students' learning motivation and academic achievement is often interpreted causally and oversimplified. This study critically examines the interplay among evaluation reform, student motivation, and learning culture while articulating the conceptual contribution of Islamic education to this discourse. It employs a critical literature review of 13 articles published within the past five years in journals indexed by SINTA 1-2 or Scopus, supplemented by seminal academic books and policy documents, and analyzed through reflexive thematic analysis. The findings indicate that the relationship between evaluation, motivation, and achievement is not direct; it is mediated by students' perceptions of assessment, motivational quality, and self-regulation, and moderated by learning culture and schools' assessment capacity. The risk of weakened learning orientation following the abolition is therefore conditional and cannot be generalized. This study proposes a conceptual model integrating the Islamic educational values of niyyah, ikhlāṣ, adab al-'ilm, amānah, mujāhadah al-nafs, and muhāsabah as mechanisms of moral and spiritual internalization that guide students from external compliance toward autonomous responsibility for learning. These findings support formative assessment aligned with Islamic principles through self-reflection, portfolios, and ethically grounded feedback. Future research should empirically examine the proposed model across diverse school and madrasah contexts.