Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search

Administrative Noncompliance and the Limits of Financial Integrity Inferences in Batu City Campaign Finance Audits Ariansyah Mustafa; Thomi Rusy Diantoro; Nuning Sri Wahyuni; Dekick Jacinda One Alvina; Ahmad Najmi Faris
Journal of Social and Humanities Vol. 4 No. 2 (2026): July-December
Publisher : Tinta Emas Publisher

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.59535/jsh.v4i2.712

Abstract

Campaign finance audits contribute to electoral accountability only when their conclusions are interpreted within the limits of the evidence examined. This study evaluates the reported funding profiles and compliance outcomes of 18 political parties contesting the Batu City legislative election in 2024. A qualitative case study combines documentary analysis of independent assurance reports with descriptive summaries of audit outcomes and selected financial disclosures. Eight parties were classified as compliant and ten as noncompliant, corresponding to 44.4% and 55.6%, respectively. Reported deficiencies concerned campaign bank accounts, reporting deadlines, document completeness, and transaction evidence. Selected disclosures also showed substantial noncash contributions and wide variation in reported campaign value. The findings distinguish formal reporting compliance, transaction traceability, and substantive financial integrity. Missing reports and unsupported expenditure can obstruct substantive verification, while internally sourced funding does not establish the absence of illicit or unreported transactions. Limited administrative capacity is a plausible explanation for some deficiencies, but the documentary evidence does not establish its causal primacy or the intentions of party officials. The study supports technical assistance combined with stronger verification of noncash contributions, clearer documentation requirements, and legally grounded responses differentiated by the nature of each breach. Its contribution is an interpretation of local audit outcomes that connects administrative support with the preservation of substantive oversight.