Ratu Eha Salhah
Universitas Jayabaya Jakarta

Published : 1 Documents Claim Missing Document
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search

A Comparative Analysis of Presidential Recruitment Systems Iin Indonesia and South Korea: Implications for Constitutional Democracy and Democratic Transformation Ratu Eha Salhah; Rotua Valentina Sagala; Hedwig Adianto
Golden Ratio of Data in Summary Vol. 6 No. 4 (2026): August - October
Publisher : Manunggal Halim Jaya

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.52970/grdis.v6i4.2410

Abstract

Indonesia and South Korea represent a good example for comparison since they are well-known Asian democracies that had gone through complex periods of transition from military and authoritarianism to democracy. This research is a qualitative and normative-comparative approach of legal research, aim to analyse similarities and differences in constitutional norms and political practices regarding the presidential recruiting systems in Indonesia and South Korea. The analysis concludes that democratic development in both Indonesia and South Korea has fundamentally shifted presidential recruitment from authoritarian control to direct popular elections, though their constitutional frameworks have evolved to address different challenges. While Indonesia and South Korea share similarities as unitary states with presidential systems and a minimum candidate age of 40, their specific constitutional mechanisms for nomination and election differ significantly. Indonesia requires candidates to be nominated in pairs (President and Vice-President) exclusively by political parties or coalitions, often utilizing a two-round voting system to ensure majority legitimacy. In contrast, South Korea allows for independent candidacy, operates without a Vice-President (utilizing an appointed Prime Minister instead), and employs a single-round plurality system for efficiency. Furthermore, South Korea maintains a more robust institutional oversight through the National Election Commission, which holds a higher constitutional standing compared to Indonesia’s electoral management bodies, ensuring stricter control over political financing and recruitment integrity. By tracing these divergences to the constitutional and party-based design of each country’s nomination process, this study contributes to the broader literature on democratic studies by clarifying how formal constitutional guarantees and informal candidate-selection practices jointly determine whether presidential recruitment reinforces oligarchic tendencies or advances democratic transformation.