Indonesia’s green sukuk market reached cumulative issuances of USD 6.9 billion by 2024, yet this growth raises an unresolved question: whether instruments labelled both green and Shariah-compliant genuinely fulfil both commitments in substantive terms. This article argues that the risk of greenwashing in green sukuk cannot be reduced solely to a technical regulatory issue, as it also implicates fundamental ethical and Islamic values. Using a systematic literature review and comparative regulatory analysis, the study identifies critical gaps between the frameworks established by POJK Regulation No. 18/2023 and AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 62 with respect to environmental-impact verification. It also examines how maqashid al-shariah, particularly hifz al-nafs (protection of life), hifz al-nasl (protection of progeny), and hifz al-mal (protection of wealth), can be operationalised as a more holistic and normative anti-greenwashing framework. The study identifies three major weaknesses: first, impact reporting relies on ex ante estimates that are not subject to mandatory verification; second, the mandate of the Shariah Supervisory Board remains confined to the fiqhiyyah aspects of contractual arrangements and does not extend to substantive ecological considerations; and third, the existing regulatory architecture lacks maqashid-based sustainability indicators. The article proposes an integrated maqashid-ESG framework for more substantive green sukuk regulation through three implementation pathways: redefining the mandate of the Shariah Supervisory Board, developing integrated maqashid-ESG indicators, and mandating post-issuance environmental-impact audits.