In recent years, learner engagement has received increasing attention due to its significant role in second language acquisition. However, few studies have compared course-level engagement across face-to-face (FTF) and synchronous online learning modalities among Vietnamese EFL university students. This study aims to address this gap by employing a mixed-methods research design to investigate the engagement of 132 university-level English-major students from the same cohort, all enrolled in a Reading and Writing 2 course at a public university in Vietnam. Participants experienced both traditional FTF and synchronous online learning environments. Quantitative data were collected via an adapted version of a validated engagement survey measuring behavioural, emotional, and cognitive dimensions of engagement. This was complemented by semi-structured interviews with selected participants to gain deeper insights into their experiences and perceptions. The quantitative results suggested that higher levels of behavioural and emotional engagement may be associated with FTF learning, while cognitive engagement remained relatively consistent across both modalities. The qualitative findings revealed that most participants preferred a blended learning format that combines the immediacy and interactional energy of FTF interaction with the flexibility of online learning. The findings highlight differences in engagement across online and FTF modalities, providing a basis for future research to investigate whether combining elements of both modalities can support multidimensional engagement.