This study analyses how the Junior Primary curriculum at the Australian Islamic College (AIC) has been developed through an approach based on multiculturalism and tolerance within the context of Australia’s diverse society. The curriculum integrates Islamic values with the Australian national curriculum, which emphasises respect for cultural diversity and the fostering of tolerant attitudes among pupils. The study employed a qualitative design involving content analysis of the JPUP Primary & Upper School Curriculum Handbook (2023), the school’s official website, and supporting policy documents, with data validity ensured through source triangulation and inter-coder agreement. The research findings indicate that multicultural values are embedded across all subjects and extracurricular activities and are reinforced by inclusive school policies and a fair assessment system. These qualitative findings are supported by performance data from the 2024 Annual Report, namely a primary school attendance rate of 93.31 per cent and a social climate index of 88.9 per cent. The novelty of this research lies in the mapping of an integrative framework linking curriculum philosophy, content, extracurricular practices, policies and assessment within the context of an Islamic minority in a Western country at the early years level—a perspective rarely explored in previous research on multicultural curricula. The main limitation of this study is its reliance on institutional documents, without classroom observations or stakeholder interviews. Nevertheless, the findings position the AIC as a relevant and adaptive model of multicultural education within Islamic education.