CV Raffa Rotan is a rattan furniture company operating a make-to-order production system in Majalengka Regency that has not implemented structured production scheduling, making it prone to delays and inefficient use of production time. This study analyzes and compares the production scheduling results of the First Come First Served (FCFS) and Shortest Processing Time (SPT) methods to determine which yields the minimum makespan. A descriptive quantitative approach was used, drawing on primary data from observation and interviews and secondary data from company documents across four periods, from the fourth quarter of 2025 through the third quarter of 2026, analyzed comparatively based on makespan and mean flow time in a two-workstation production system. Results show that SPT consistently reduced mean flow time, with an average reduction of 22.65% compared to FCFS across all periods. However, the makespan produced by SPT was consistently higher than FCFS across all four periods, with an average difference of 2.22%, since SPT does not account for workload distribution between stations separately. Thus, FCFS proved more effective in minimizing makespan in the two-workstation production system at CV Raffa Rotan and is recommended as the more suitable scheduling method for the company.