Objective: To examine whether disciplinary affiliation differentiates vocational students’ perceptions of Cyber-Physical Learning (CPL) and Immersive Learning (ILM) support for creative thinking and problem solving. It further considered the findings within a hardware–software convergence framework and their implications for competency-centered vocational education relevant to Sustainable Development Goal 4 (SDG 4). Method: A quantitative, comparative, cross-sectional survey was conducted using purposive sampling at Universitas Negeri Surabaya. The analysis included 222 valid respondents, comprising 109 Electrical Engineering and 113 Informatics Management students. A 31-item questionnaire using a five-point Likert scale assessed four perceived-support constructs: CPL for creative thinking (CPL-CT), CPL for problem solving (CPL-PS), ILM for creative thinking (ILM-CT), and ILM for problem solving (ILM-PS). Four independent-group Mann-Whitney U tests compared the two programs, supplemented by approximate standardized rank-test indicators derived from the reported Z statistics. Results: No statistically significant between-program differences were detected for CPL-CT (p = .663), CPL-PS (p = .585), ILM-CT (p = .636), or ILM_PS (p = .689). The derived standardized indicators were numerically small (r= .027–.037). These findings concern perceived learning support rather than demonstrated learning gains and do not establish practical equivalence or verify the proposed hardware–software convergence mechanism. Novelty: The study provides a cross-disciplinary assessment of four perceived learning affordances rather than comparing the superiority of particular technologies. The findings support consideration of competency-centered access to cyber-physical and immersive learning across vocational programs, with relevance to SDG 4. However, the study does not directly measure SDG attainment, actual skill development, or causal learning effects.