Aik Nai Chiek Aik Nai Chiek
Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman, Malaysia

Published : 2 Documents Claim Missing Document
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search

Dividend policy and ESG disclosure substitution: Evidence from Malaysia Aik Nai Chiek Aik Nai Chiek; Raymond Ling Leh Bin Raymond Ling Leh Bin
CoMBInES - Conference on Management, Business, Innovation, Education and Social Sciences Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): The 6th Conference on Management, Business, Innovation, Education and Social Sc
Publisher : Universitas Internasional Batam

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.37253/combines.v6i1.12740

Abstract

In markets characterised by information asymmetry, investors do not share equal access to firm-specific information, leading to uncertainty regarding a company’s true value (Malik & Kashiramka, 2025). Signaling theory posits that firms undertake observable actions to reduce such uncertainty and enhance credibility (Connelly et al., 2011; Hasan & Al-Najjar, 2025). Within this framework, dividend policy has long been recognised as a key financial signal and reflects the extent to which firms prioritise shareholder returns over earnings retention (DeAngelo et al., 2000; AlGhazali et al., 2023). Dividend payments can therefore serve as credible indicators of firm and managerial quality, particularly when alternative disclosures are limited or less reliable (Bhattacharya, 1979; Salvi et al., 2023). Extending this perspective beyond financial signals, firms are increasingly expected to provide transparent and credible ESG disclosures to reduce information asymmetry in investment decisions (Chen et al., 2024). ESG broadly captures how firms manage environmental impact, stakeholder relationships, and governance structures (Gherghina, 2024). Specifically, environmental dimension relates to resource use and emissions, the social dimension concerns stakeholder welfare, and the governance dimension reflects leadership quality and ethical conduct (Aydoğmuş et al., 2022). At the global level, mandatory ESG disclosure is intended to reduce information gaps and enhance comparability across firms (Krueger et al., 2024). In Malaysia, the introduction of the National Sustainability Reporting Framework (NSRF) on 24 September 2024 by the Securities Commission Malaysia marks a significant regulatory shift. However, prior practices were largely shaped by a weakly regulated environment. In the pre-NSRF period, the absence of uniform standards and weak enforcement limited the comparability and reliability of ESG disclosures, constraining their effectiveness in mitigating information asymmetry (Almulhim et al., 2024). Under such conditions, disclosure inconsistencies are not merely incidental but structural, potentially prompting firms to rely on alternative signals to convey credibility. Within the Malaysian context, these dynamics highlight the relevance of signal substitution in markets with evolving ESG practices. Dividend policy can function as a substitute, with higher payouts compensating for weaker ESG transparency (Ananzeh et al., 2024), or as a complement, where stable dividends reinforce strong ESG disclosure (Wan Mohammad & Wasiuzzaman, 2021). Malaysia thus provides a timely setting to examine how firms strategically deploy financial and non-financial mechanisms to mitigate information asymmetry. This study addresses this gap by empirically testing whether dividend policy functions as an alternative signal to ESG disclosure among Malaysian listed firms. It focuses on three research questions: (1) Does the level of ESG disclosure affect dividend payout policy? (2) Do firms with lower ESG transparency pay higher dividends, consistent with a substitution effect? (3) Do firms with higher ESG transparency also exhibit higher dividend payouts, indicating complementarity? In line with these questions, the study sets out three objectives. The first is to examine the relationship between ESG disclosure levels, proxied by the ESG disclosure ratio and Controversies-adjusted ESG (ESGC) score, and dividend payout policy. The second is to test whether firms with lower ESG transparency use higher dividend payouts as a substitute signaling mechanism. The third is to assess whether firms with higher ESG transparency exhibit higher dividend payouts, indicating a complementary signaling effect. Examining the link between dividend payout and ESG transparency requires an integrated theoretical perspective. This study draws on signaling theory, agency theory, and stakeholder theory to develop testable hypotheses. Spence (1973) develops signalling theory to explain how firms convey unobservable attributes to markets under conditions of information asymmetry. Financial and non financial disclosures reduce this asymmetry by transmitting information to investors (Dumay, 2016; Dua & Sharma, 2024). In Malaysia, highly leveraged firms continued paying dividends during the COVID-19 period to signal financial stability and maintain investor confidence (Syarifah & Hersugondo, 2024). In ESG studies, higher ESG scores are linked to more stable dividend policies, indicating a complementary relationship between ESG disclosure and dividend payouts (Casey, 2020; Ismillah & Faisal, 2023). Agency theory complements signalling theory by viewing dividends as a mechanism to align managerial and shareholder interests and reduce agency conflicts arising from managerial opportunism (Jensen, 1986). By distributing excess cash, dividend payments limit the resources available for potential misuse by insiders. Firms with higher ESG scores are therefore expected to pay higher dividends (Verga Matos et al., 2020). Stakeholder theory highlights firms’ responsibilities to multiple stakeholder groups (Donaldson & Preston, 1995; Freeman, 2010). Zahid et al. (2023) show that firms prioritising ESG initiatives combined with higher dividend payouts help align the interests of diverse stakeholder groups. Similarly, Shehata et al. (2025) find a significant positive relationship between ESG scores and dividend payouts in stakeholder-oriented firms. While ESG disclosure captures planned reporting of ESG practices, it does not fully reflect market perceptions when adverse events occur. ESG controversies, defined as negative events or disclosures related to ESG practices, indicate failures in responsible conduct and draw stakeholder scrutiny (Dorfleitner et al., 2020; Schiemann & Tietmeyer, 2022). Unlike voluntary disclosure, they represent realised risks that increase uncertainty, erode trust, and may influence dividend decisions as firms seek to restore credibility (Aouadi & Marsat, 2018; DasGupta, 2022). This highlights the importance of incorporating ESG controversies when examining ESG-related signalling. Empirical studies present two views on the ESG–dividend relationship. The complementary view links stronger ESG performance to higher and more stable dividends through improved governance, lower risk, and stronger stakeholder confidence (Bilyay-Erdogan et al., 2023; Hampl & Vágnerová Linnertová, 2025), a pattern more evident in developed markets than in emerging economies with uneven disclosure quality. The substitution view suggests that dividends may offset weak ESG disclosure, particularly in emerging markets, where firms adjust payouts to maintain investor confidence (Grullon & Michaely, 2002; Akpadaka et al., 2024). These findings indicate that dividends function as either substitute or complementary signals depending on ESG disclosure quality, supporting the formulation of three hypotheses. The hypotheses in this study distinguish between a general association and two competing explanations of firm behaviour. The first hypothesis (H1) proposes that ESG disclosure is significantly associated with dividend payout, without specifying the direction of the relationship. The substitution hypothesis (H2) predicts a negative relationship between ESG disclosure and dividend payout, where firms with weaker ESG transparency pay higher dividends to compensate for limited non-financial disclosure. In contrast, the complementarity hypothesis (H3) predicts a positive relationship, indicating that firms with stronger ESG transparency also pay higher dividends to reinforce investor confidence through consistent signaling. To test these hypotheses, the study employs two regression models using alternative ESG measures. The first model uses the ESG disclosure ratio, which captures the extent of ESG information disclosed and serves as a proxy for disclosure intensity and transparency. The second model uses the ESGC score, which incorporates both ESG disclosure quality and adjustments for corporate controversies and therefore represents a quality-adjusted measure of ESG performance. Using both measures helps ensure that the empirical results are robust across different dimensions of ESG transparency. The estimated coefficient signs are used to distinguish between the competing explanations. A negative relationship supports the substitution view grounded in agency and stakeholder theories, where dividends act as a substitute mechanism to compensate for weaker ESG disclosure and reduce investor uncertainty. A positive relationship supports the complementarity view consistent with signaling theory, where firms with stronger ESG performance pair higher-quality ESG disclosure with higher dividend payouts to strengthen investor confidence. Dividend policy (DIVit) is measured using the dividend payout ratio for firm i in year t. ESG transparency is proxied by the ESG disclosure score (ESG Disclosure Scoreit) and the controversies-adjusted ESG score (ESGC Scoreit). The ESG disclosure score is constructed from LSEG raw ESG data based on publicly available disclosures. Each item within the Environmental (306 items), Social (278 items), and Governance (177 items) pillars is coded as 1 if disclosed and 0 otherwise. Pillar scores are computed as the proportion of disclosed items, and the overall ESG disclosure score is obtained as the average of the three pillar scores. The ESGC score is obtained directly from LSEG. The study controls for firm characteristics that may influence dividend payout. Profitability (Profitabilityit) is included since more profitable firms tend to generate higher free cash flowand are more likely to pay dividends (Januarsi & Sanusi, 2024). It is measured by return on assets. Leverage (Leverageit) is considered because higher debt can restrict dividend payments when lenders impose constraints to protect their interests (Nasrulloh, 2024). It is measured as total liabilities divided by total assets. Firm size (Sizeit) is included as larger firms are generally more likely to pay dividends (Sirait et al., 2025). It is measured as the natural logarithm of total assets. Growth opportunities (Growthit) are captured based on the firm life-cycle hypothesis, where firms with stronger growth prospects tend to retain earnings rather than distribute them (Thapa, 2021). Growth is proxied by the market-to-book ratio. The study employs panel regression analysis using firm-level data over time. All models include firm fixed effects to control for time-invariant unobserved heterogeneity and year fixed effects to capture unobserved time-specific macroeconomic shocks affecting all firms. Standard errors are clustered at the firm level to account for serial correlation and heteroskedasticity. Observations with missing values in key variables are excluded using listwise deletion. To reduce the influence of extreme values, all continuous variables are winsorised at the 1st and 99th percentiles. The empirical analysis draws on panel data from firms listed on the Main Market of Bursa Malaysia, excluding financial services firms, over the period 2018 to 2024. ESG coverage for Malaysian firms becomes more complete after 2017, making this period suitable for analysis. Financial firms are excluded because they operate under distinct regulatory frameworks and accounting practices, which limit comparability with non financial sectors. All data are sourced from the LSEG database. This study contributes by providing empirical evidence on signaling substitution between ESG disclosure and dividend policy in an emerging market with uneven ESG reporting, offering insights into how firms manage information asymmetry through payout decisions.
Diagnosing Open Finance Regulatory Readiness in ASEAN-6: A Content Analysis Index Construction with Policy Implications for Malaysia Mah Hui Ying Mah Hui Ying; Aik Nai Chiek Aik Nai Chiek; Tee Peck Ling Tee Peck Ling
CoMBInES - Conference on Management, Business, Innovation, Education and Social Sciences Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): The 6th Conference on Management, Business, Innovation, Education and Social Sc
Publisher : Universitas Internasional Batam

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.37253/combines.v6i1.12792

Abstract

Open finance refers to the sharing and use of customer-permissioned data by financial institutions with third-party firms, other financial institutions and developers to build applications and services (Eroglu et al., 2026). It is broader than open banking because open banking mainly focuses on bank account and payment-related data, while open finance may cover wider financial products such as insurance, investment, lending and mortgages (Eroglu et al., 2026). Through standardised application programming interfaces (APIs), open finance enables customer data to be shared in a more secure, consistent and consent-driven way. This technical architecture creates a foundation for alternative credit assessment based on transactional and behavioural data, personalised financial products and embedded finance services. For developing economies, open finance is relevant because it may help widen access to credit for individuals and firms that lack collateral or formal credit histories (Babina et al., 2025). However, these benefits should not be assumed automatically, as open finance also creates regulatory and market risks involving informed consent, data protection, cyber-fraud, algorithmic discrimination, market concentration and the potential dominance of data aggregators (Awrey & Macey, 2023). Successful open finance implementation therefore requires more than a policy mandate. According to Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Paper No. 168, successful implementation depends on standardised data-sharing protocols, interoperability and robust regulatory frameworks (Eroglu et al., 2026). This makes regulatory readiness important because open finance requires more than technical data sharing. It also requires clear rules on consent, data protection, third-party oversight, interoperability and accountability to prevent risks such as data breaches, cyber-fraud, algorithmic discrimination, market concentration and the potential dominance of data aggregators (Awrey & Macey, 2023). These conditions matter most in emerging markets where digital finance development, regulatory maturity and institutional capacity differ substantially across jurisdictions. In Malaysia, this issue became more important after Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) issued its Exposure Draft (ED) on Open Finance in November 2025. The ED proposes a framework for consent-driven sharing of customer information across the financial sector in a secure, open, accessible, interoperable and timely manner (BNM, 2025). The proposed implementation is planned in three phases: institutions with more than one million customers from January 2027, institutions with more than 100,000 customers from January 2028, and development financial institutions and e-money issuers from January 2029 (BNM, 2025). This study is motivated by Malaysia’s proposed open finance timeline and the uneven development of open finance readiness across six major Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) economies: Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam. These six economies are selected because they are frequently compared in Southeast Asian open banking analysis. Twimbit’s State of Open Banking in Southeast Asia evaluates these same countries across infrastructure readiness, open finance frameworks, digital payment infrastructure, regulatory sandboxes and digital banking models, indicating that they form a relevant comparison group for assessing regional open finance readiness (Twimbit, 2024). The ASEAN Open Finance Readiness Index (AOFRI) is developed in this study as a regulatory readiness scoring instrument applied across the six ASEAN economies. The UK is used as a mature open banking benchmark because the Competition and Markets Authority required the nine largest current account providers to establish and fund the Open Banking Implementation Entity and implement standardised open banking arrangements (Competition and Markets Authority, 2021). Brazil is used as a broader open finance benchmark because its framework has been implemented in phases covering institutional data, customer data, payment initiation and loan proposal services (Banco Central do Brasil, n.d.). Together, the UK and Brazil provide reference points for defining higher levels of regulatory readiness within the AOFRI framework. Three research gaps motivate this study. First, ASEAN-6 economies remain underrepresented in comparative open finance research. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) survey on data-sharing frameworks covers 34 jurisdictions and examines issues such as mandatory data sharing, third-party provider authorisation, API obligations and consent frameworks, but it does not include ASEAN economies (OECD, 2023). The Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance (CCAF) and Asian Development Bank Institute (ADBI) also classify open banking and open finance governance approaches across Asia-Pacific, but they do not develop an indicator-level composite readiness index for ASEAN-6 (CCAF & ADBI, 2025). Second, the financial inclusion rationale used to justify open finance still requires stronger pre implementation assessment. Open finance is often promoted as a way to improve access to credit and financial services. However, existing evidence shows that the benefits may not be evenly distributed. Babina et al. (2025) find that open banking can support fintech entry and new lending relationships, but some benefits may be larger for consumers and firms that are already able to participate in the financial system. Preziuso, Koefer and Ehrenhard (2023) also argue that research on open banking and financial inclusion remains limited and fragmented. This suggests that financial inclusion should not be assumed as an automatic outcome of open finance. Instead, researchers should first assess whether the regulatory conditions needed to support inclusive outcomes are present. Third, Malaysia’s proposed regulatory pathway raises a specific readiness concern. In many jurisdictions, open banking frameworks are first established before the scope expands into broader open finance (Eroglu et al., 2026). The UK developed a mandatory open banking framework before moving towards wider financial data-sharing discussions, while Brazil implemented open finance gradually through different phases (Competition and Markets Authority, 2021; Banco Central do Brasil, n.d.). By contrast, Malaysia is proposing open finance implementation without first having a fully mandatory consumer-permissioned open banking regime. This raises an important research question: whether Malaysia’s current de jure regulatory framework provides a strong enough foundation for the proposed implementation timeline. The study has two main research objectives. The first objective is to assess the completeness of ASEAN-6 open finance regulatory frameworks compared with frontier benchmark jurisdictions. The second objective is to identify Malaysia’s regulatory gaps and provide ranked policy considerations for BNM before the January 2027 implementation timeline. Based on these objectives, three hypotheses are developed. H1 proposes that ASEAN-6 economies show different levels of regulatory readiness across the five AOFRI dimensions. H2 proposes that Singapore scores above the ASEAN-6 average, while Malaysia scores below it. H3 proposes that Malaysia’s AOFRI score falls below the current regulatory profiles of the UK and Brazil, especially in dimensions related to regulatory mandate and implementation governance. AOFRI is supported by Regulatory Theory and Financial Inclusion Theory. Regulatory Theory explains that effective regulation requires clear standards, monitoring capacity, behaviour modification, enforcement and legitimacy (Baldwin, Cave, & Lodge, 2012). This theory supports the need to assess whether open finance rules are clear, binding and enforceable. Financial Inclusion Theory explains that financial systems should expand access to underserved individuals and firms, especially those excluded by traditional credit assessment methods (Demirgüç-Kunt & Klapper, 2012). This theory supports the study’s focus on whether open finance regulation can create the conditions needed for more inclusive financial access. Methodologically, AOFRI uses a content analysis approach adapted from Barth, Caprio and Levine’s regulatory scoring method (Barth, Caprio, & Levine, 2013). The unit of analysis is the country-level regulatory framework, using the same ASEAN-6 jurisdictions and benchmark cases form the analytical sample. The study relies entirely on secondary documentary sources, including central bank publications, financial regulator documents, exposure drafts, open finance and open banking frameworks, API-related policy documents and other official policy materials, as listed in the Appendix. This source selection allows the study to focus on de jure regulatory readiness, namely the extent to which formal rules, policy directions and implementation arrangements have been established in each jurisdiction. The five AOFRI dimensions are derived from the Alliance for Financial Inclusion (AFI) Policy Development and Implementation Guide for Inclusive Open Finance. These dimensions are Regulatory Authority and Governance; Ecosystem Design and Participants; Policy Provisions; Data, APIs and Security Specifications; and Implementation and Monitoring (AFI, 2025). Each jurisdiction’s documents are reviewed to assess the presence, scope and maturity of open finance-related regulatory provisions. The comparative analysis is then used to identify differences across ASEAN-6 and highlight Malaysia’s key regulatory gaps before its proposed open finance implementation timeline. This study contributes to open finance research by developing an indicator-level regulatory readiness index for ASEAN-6. It also provides a structured diagnostic of Malaysia’s regulatory foundation before the proposed January 2027 implementation timeline. The findings are expected to help identify whether Malaysia’s open finance framework is sufficiently developed and which regulatory areas require further strengthening before implementation.