Background: Kleinhovia hospita Linn. (tahongai) leaves are used in Indonesian traditional medicine, but quality specifications for their extracts are not yet defined. Extracts prepared with different solvents have not been compared using the same quality parameters. Objective: To compare the specific and non-specific quality parameters of five tahongai leaf extracts prepared with solvents of different polarity. Methods: Five extracts of leaves from Belitang, South Sumatra, were compared: three sequential macerates (n-hexane, ethyl acetate, residual ethanol) from our earlier cytotoxicity study, a single 96% ethanol macerate, and an infusion. The extracts were evaluated for thin layer chromatography (TLC) detection of quercetin and kaempferol, extractive values, specific gravity, loss on drying, moisture, ash values, and microbial counts. Moisture (≤10%) and microbial limits followed Indonesian regulatory requirements. Results: Single maceration and infusion gave yields of 32.36% and 44.61%, respectively. The 96% ethanol extract had the highest ethanol-soluble extractive (35.87%) and contained alkaloids, flavonoids, tannins, saponins, and steroids. Four of five extracts met the moisture limit (3.37–9.42%), whereas the infusion did not (17.33%). All extracts met the microbial limits (total plate count ≤1.2 × 103 CFU/g; mould and yeast ≤5.8 × 102 CFU/g). Only the ethyl acetate extract showed a spot consistent with quercetin (Rf 0.32 vs 0.35), and kaempferol was not confirmed in any extract. Conclusion: Solvent polarity determined the composition and quality of tahongai leaf extracts. The 96% ethanol and ethyl acetate extracts are the most suitable candidates for further standardization, which will require replicate data and quantitative marker assays.