Advances in information and communication technology have expanded the scope of freedom of expression for the public, but at the same time have presented challenges for law enforcement in the digital realm. One of the issues that has arisen is the potential for overcriminalization in the application of the Electronic Information and Transactions Law (ITE Law), particularly regarding expressions related to criticism, opinions, and the public interest. This study aims to analyze the potential for overcriminalization under the ITE Law and its implications for the protection of freedom of expression in Indonesia. This study employs a normative legal methodology using legislative, conceptual, and case-based approaches. Legal materials are analyzed qualitatively with reference to the principles of legality, proportionality of punishment, ultimum remedium, and standards for the protection of freedom of expression based on the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. The analysis shows that the potential for overcriminalization can arise when the wording or application of criminal provisions is interpreted broadly, thereby blurring the line between legitimate criticism and acts that constitute a criminal offense. Such conditions have the potential to create a chilling effect, reduce public participation in public discourse, and hinder the function of democratic oversight. The amendment to the ITE Law through Law No. 1 of 2024 is a normative step toward improving the legal framework, but its effectiveness remains dependent on the clarity of the legal norms and the consistency of law enforcement. This study concludes that preventing overcriminalization requires careful, proportional, and human rights-oriented application of the law, without neglecting the protection of an individual’s dignity and reputation.