Indonesia has granted legal autonomy to twenty-four of its state universities, the PTN BH institutions, giving them independent control over finance, tuition, and academic portfolios in exchange for the expectation that they compete as world class universities. Autonomy makes marketing consequential, because these institutions now depend on the enrolments and partnerships their public presentation can win, and their websites are the shop window in which that presentation happens. Yet no study has systematically evaluated how well the autonomous flagship tier of any large Global South system performs on its primary owned digital channel. This study audits the complete population of PTN BH websites using the Digital Marketing Maturity Index, a forty-two-indicator instrument that integrates the RACE planning framework, the 7Cs of customer interface design, and website quality theory across six dimensions, with every institution fully double coded by two trained coders and benchmarked against a panel of twenty leading Southeast Asian universities. The design combines automated technical auditing, manual content analysis of each institution's recruitment funnel, structural analysis of template similarity, and qualitative coding of institutional identity. The findings document a flagship tier that is technically competent and content rich but persistently weak in conversion architecture, a maturity gradient that follows the length of autonomy experience across the three PTN BH cohorts, a regional gap with Southeast Asian leaders concentrated in conversion and international discoverability, and a pronounced identity vacuum in which the institutions that set the template for four thousand imitators have themselves largely declined to say who they are. The study contributes a transferable audit instrument, the first complete population evidence on flagship digital marketing in Indonesia, and an extension of institutional isomorphism theory to the digital self presentation of the organisations at the top of an organisational field.