Constraints in power, memory, computational capacity, and bandwidth render the selection of communication protocols a critical decision in the deployment of the Internet of Things (IoT). Although MQTT and CoAP are both engineered for lightweight communication, they utilize distinct communication models and transport mechanisms; consequently, their performance cannot be accurately evaluated based on a single parameter or a single network topology. This study employs a library research approach, conducting an integrative literature review of relevant academic books, journal articles, scientific proceedings, and research reports. The synthesis of the literature reveals four primary findings. First, MQTT is generally well-suited for publish/subscribe-based telemetry, broad message distribution to multiple consumers, and broker-mediated integration; however, the reliability of TCP and Quality of Service (QoS) levels may introduce additional overhead and latency. Second, CoAP provides a concise request/response exchange mechanism over UDP, demonstrating greater bandwidth efficiency for small messages, though message reliability, retransmission, and security parameters still require explicit configuration. Third, the implementation of star, tree, mesh, and hybrid topologies fundamentally alters the number of hops, channel contention, congestion points, and energy expenditures; thus, the comparative performance ranking of these protocols is highly contingent upon the underlying network design. Fourth, valid benchmarking methodologies must rigorously and comparably control variables such as payload size, message intervals, node density, channel conditions, security protocols, and QoS configurations. This study concludes that protocol selection must be driven by specific application requirements rather than assertions of universal efficacy. The resulting evaluation framework aims to assist IoT architects in designing replicable performance tests and selecting optimal protocol-topology combinations tailored to specific resource constraints.