Purpose of the study: This article aims to comparatively analyze how courts in Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines develop legal considerations as well as impose sanctions in cases of illegal fishing criminal acts, by emphasizing differences in the legal systems, criminal policy orientations, and their implications for the enforcement of maritime law. Methodology: This was normative legal research which employed the library research method. It employed the statute, case, and comparative approaches, focusing on the analysis of court decisions as the main legal sources without conducting research in the field. The data were obtained through literary studies on legal regulations, court decisions with permanent binding power, as well as relevant literature on criminal law and international maritime law. Result: Research results show that there are fundamental differences in the construction of judges’ legal considerations and the sanctioning patterns on illegal fishing, where the Indonesian justice system tends to emphasize the aspect of national interests and sovereignty. Meanwhile, the Malaysian court orients towards legal certainty and normative compliance through economic sanctions. Next, the court of the Philippines integrates the criminal law approach with the goal of coastal resource management and the protection of the people’s interests. Applications of this study: The function of this research lies in its contribution to providing a more comprehensive understanding of the practice of maritime criminal justice in the Southeast Asian territory, as well as a reference material for policymakers and law enforcement agencies in formulating a more effective and contextual strategy to overcome the crime of illegal fishing. Novelty/Originality of this study: This research’s novelty is its focus on analyzing and comparing the court decisions of different countries as the main instrument to read the orientation of maritime criminal law policies, which are so far more commonly analyzed from the normative and international cooperation aspects. Thus, it offers a new perspective on the role of courts in increasing the effectiveness of law enforcement in the fisheries sector. Keywords: maritime criminal law; illegal fishing; maritime sovereignty; court decisions; legal comparison