Harri Dolli Hutabarat
Universitas Pertahanan

Published : 2 Documents Claim Missing Document
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search

Who Leads Recovery? Interagency Coordination and Collaborative Governance after Social Conflict in Indonesia Tika Jayanti Purba; Harri Dolli Hutabarat; Hendra Manurung; Nefra Firdaus; Arifudin Uksan
Jurnal Ilmu Administrasi Negara (JUAN) Vol 14 No 2 (2026): November, 2026
Publisher : Program Studi Ilmu Administrasi Negara FISIP UMRAH

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31629/juan.v14i2.8838

Abstract

Indonesia’s social conflict framework assigns a central coordinating mandate to the Ministry of Home Affairs, whereas crucial financing and operational instruments for post-conflict recovery remain embedded in disaster governance. This article examines interagency leadership, coordination, and implementation constraints through comparative qualitative document analysis of the West Adonara conflict in East Flores during 2024–2025 and the Banemo–Sibenpopo conflict in Central Halmahera during 2026. Evidence comprises legislation, government reports, ministerial meeting materials, and interagency coordination records. Findings reveal three interconnected patterns. First, the social conflict and disaster management regimes define different administrative mandates, emergency statuses, and financing procedures, creating an institutional gap between formal leadership and access to recovery resources. Second, officials respond by adapting or borrowing disaster mechanisms: the Adonara response required exceptional presidential authorization, while Central Halmahera used a social conflict disaster designation to access recovery arrangements. Third, coordination gravitates toward organizations controlling budgets and implementation instruments, even when another ministry holds the formal mandate. Differences across official damage and displacement records further complicate joint planning. Presidential Regulation No. 46 of 2026 partially addresses the regulatory mismatch, but cannot alone establish coherent institutional responsibilities. The article concludes that sustainable recovery requires explicit financing rules, interoperable information, clarified agency roles, and alignment between social conflict management and disaster recovery procedures. The findings are document-based and do not establish causal effects or household-level recovery outcomes. Fieldwork should test these proposed coordination mechanisms.
Ritual Governance and Kinship Restoration: Lamaholot Customary Reconciliation after the 2026 Bele–Lewonara Land Conflict Maria Theresia Y Rainy Tukan; Margaretha Hanita; Ferdinand Hasudungan Siagian; Arifuddin Uksan; Harri Dolli Hutabarat
Jurnal Ilmu Administrasi Negara (JUAN) Vol 14 No 2 (2026): November, 2026
Publisher : Program Studi Ilmu Administrasi Negara FISIP UMRAH

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31629/juan.v14i2.8840

Abstract

Customary land conflicts on Adonara Island in Indonesia can disrupt relationships among groups that understand themselves as kin. The Lamaholot concept of kenetun captures this rupture, which cannot be addressed through a cessation of violence alone. This article examines ritual governance and kinship reaffirmation in the reconciliation following the 2026 Bele–Lewonara conflict. Using interpretive qualitative document analysis, the study compares scholarly accounts of mela sare and hodi limat with seven reports and releases concerning the conflict and the ceremony held on 10 August 2026. John Paul Lederach's relational approach supplies the theoretical framework, with attention to truth, mercy, justice, and peace. Four analytical categories emerge from the customary repertoire: reciprocal giving and receiving, mixing palm wine and drinking together, sharing meals, and joining hands or dancing collectively. These actions primarily express renewed acceptance and the aspiration to peaceful association, while questions of truth and justice require additional procedures. The August ceremony retained a customary oath, Bau Lolon, and invocation before Rera Wulan Tana Ekan, while incorporating a written peace record, governmental witnesses, and a church venue. Customary elders continued to perform the recognised ritual acts. The findings indicate that reconciliation publicly reaffirms pre-existing kinship rather than necessarily creating new bonds. Documentary limitations prevent conclusions about lasting peace, unresolved land boundaries, or the complete performance of traditional actions during the ceremony. The study contributes an institutionally differentiated account of customary reconciliation.