Indonesia’s correctional system faces a persistent overcapacity crisis, with recent official data indicating that prisons in several jurisdictions operate at nearly twice their intended capacity, threatening prisoners’ basic rights, obstructing rehabilitation, and increasing the risk of recidivism. While existing responses have largely focused on downstream measures such as building or expanding prisons and transferring prisoners between institutions, this article argues that overcapacity is also produced upstream by carceral culture, namely a legal and institutional orientation that treats imprisonment as the principal indicator of justice. Using a juridical-normative method integrated with a socio-legal approach, this study examines how legal education, criminalization practices, pretrial detention, prosecutorial and judicial decision-making, institutional performance indicators, and punitive public opinion hinder the implementation of non-custodial sanctions. The study is timely following the enactment of Law Number 1 of 2023 on the National Criminal Code, which expands the legal basis for fines, supervision, social work, and other non-custodial sanctions, but whose progressive potential may be undermined by persistent cultural and institutional resistance. The article proposes an upstream model for challenging carceral culture through reform of legal curricula and professional training, performance indicators that reward diversion and restorative case resolution, sentencing guidelines prioritizing proportionate non-custodial sanctions, strengthened supervision by correctional centres, and public legal literacy. Restorative justice is understood as repairing harm and restoring relationships among victims, offenders, and affected communities, whereas rehabilitative justice concerns behavioural change and lawful social reintegration. Public legal literacy refers to educating citizens about the effectiveness, safeguards, and accountability of alternatives to imprisonment, thereby reducing pressure for unnecessarily harsh sentences. The article concludes that resolving overcapacity requires not only additional prison infrastructure but also institutional and cultural.