Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 3 Documents
Search

New Terrorism: What Can the History of Terrorism Contribute? Nazala, Rochdi Mohan
Jurnal Hubungan Internasional Vol 8, No 1 (2019): April
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.18196/hi.81149

Abstract

Whether or not the realm of terrorism has significantly transformed in the past three decades is one of major debates in the field of political violence today. Proponents of new terrorism argue that current terrorists are more religious inspired and lethal, depend less on state’s support and have changed their nature in term of organizational structure. On the other hand, some refuse the idea of new terrorism and, instead, argue that there is only continuity regarding terrorist acts. This paper attempts to clarify the debates through a historical investigation within the history of terrorism and it reveals that characteristics brought by the concept of new terrorism are valid to describe the current status of terrorism. However, by looking at some evidences in terrorism history, this paper also found out that those features are less unique to terrorism operatives nowadays due to the fact that perpetrators’ activities in the past have similar attributes.
ISIS, GENOCIDE AND A “THICK DESCRIPTION” OF POWER Nazala, Rochdi Mohan
Jurnal Transformasi Global Vol. 6 No. 2 (2019): Jurnal Transformasi Global (JTG)
Publisher : Department of International Relations, Brawijaya University

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21776/jtg.v6i2.118

Abstract

IntroductionOn August 3, 2015, Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) fighters were marching with full military equipment to Kocho, a village that belongs to Yazidi, one of the minorities in Iraq, near Mount Sinjar (Kikoler, 2015). They captured 1200 men, women and children whom in the next two days ISIS told to leave their religious practice, which is a combination of elements of Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam and to convert to Islam. When the majority of Yazidi's men refused the demand, all of them were taken with their eyes blindfolded around 500 meters outside the village, and upon arriving at the destination, they were lined up, videotaped and shot (Amnesty International Canada, August 18, 2014). The women became sex slaves (Smith, 2014) and the children were transferred to ISIS’s camp to train as soldiers (McLaughlin, 2016).The story above from Kocho is a one of frames that is used repeatedly to justify the allegation of ISIS conducting genocide toward Yazidi as well as other minorities in Iraq and Syria. The European Union, for instance, announced in the beginning of 2016 that ISIS was "committing genocide against Christians and Yazidis, and other religious and ethnic minorities (Brown, 2016). Later, this statement was followed by the announcement of the US government in March 2016 that stated ISIS “is responsible for genocide against groups in areas under its control, including Yazidis, Christian and Shiite Muslims” (Labott & Kopan, 2016). Huy  (2010) in his comment on the book of one Khmer Rouge’s survivor, Bou Meng, says genocide “has always been a political act, and always will be.” Politics, according to Morgenthou (1985), is about interest defining in terms of power. Indeed, as one of the ISIS's fighters says above, by joining ISIS and subsequently becoming involved in genocidal acts, it brings them the feeling of being free. According to the Oxford English Dictionary (OED), to be free means to be “able to act as one wishes, determining one’s own action or choice; done or made without compulsion or constraint” (Oxford English Dictionary online, 2016). In other words, the perpetrators acknowledge that their ruthless behaviors are the sign of power because, as it is written in the OED, power creates a sense of the  “ability to act or affect something strongly; [exhibiting] physical or mental strength” (Oxford English Dictionary online, 2016). How can genocidal acts be political while also creating a sense of power within the perpetrators?  To what extent do the atrocious acts of mass killings, sex slavery as well as human trafficking involving children create a sense of power to ISIS’s fighters? This essay aims to construct a "thick description" of power within ISIS’s genocidal acts. The ideas brought forth is that genocide as it was against Yazidi reflects the meaning ISIS’s members give to power and how it operates in social life. 
Middle and Emerging Power in Foreign Policy Analysis Nazala, Rochdi Mohan
Global Strategis Vol. 19 No. 2 (2025): Global Strategis
Publisher : Department of International Relations, Faculty of Social and Political Science, Universitas Airlangga

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.20473/jgs.19.2.2025.207-230

Abstract

This paper argues that the concepts of ‘middle powers’ and ‘emerging powers’ remain analytically ambiguous and often conflated, owing to overlapping parameters and inconsistent theoretical frameworks. While both terms have been widely employed in the study of International Relations – particularly in foreign policy analysis since the early 2000s – they suffer from conceptual limitations that weaken their analytical utility. The long-standing debate over the appropriate variables for defining a ‘middle power’ has led to the development of multiple, sometimes conflicting, approaches: functional, systemic-structural, psychological, behavioral, positional, and identity. At the same time, the term ‘emerging powers’ has been criticized as vague or even meaningless, as it often adopts criteria from classical middle power theories without sufficient conceptual distinction. Through a literature-based analysis, this paper explores how the definitional debates around 'middle powers' originated, how the term 'emerging powers' emerged and became entangled with it, and how recent scholars – such as that by Fonseca et al. and Paes et al. – has attempted to reconceptualize ‘emerging powers’ using more fluid, context-sensitive, and narrative-driven frameworks. In doing so, the study highlights the need for clearer conceptual boundaries to enhance both academic rigor and policy relevance in analyzing state roles in the evolving international system. Keywords: Middle Powers, Emerging Powers, Foreign Policy Analysis, International Politics, International System Penelitian ini berargumen konsep ‘middle powers’ dan ‘emerging powers’ masih bersifat ambigu secara analitis dan sering kali tumpang tindih. Hal ini disebabkan oleh parameter yang saling beririsan serta penerapan teori yang tidak konsisten. Kedua istilah ini telah digunakan secara luas dalam studi Hubungan Internasional, khususnya dalam analisis kebijakan luar negeri sejak awal milenium baru, untuk mengkaji kemunculan negara-negara yang telah menjadi atau diperkirakan akan menjadi aktor penting dalam sistem internasional. Namun, keduanya menghadapi masalah konseptual yang signifikan. Perdebatan panjang mengenai variabel yang tepat untuk mengkategorikan suatu negara sebagai ‘middle power’ telah melahirkan berbagai pendekatan: fungsional, struktural-sistemik, psikologi, perilaku, posisi, dan identitas. Perdebatan yang muncul dalam upaya mendefinisikan ‘middle powers’ tersebut hingga saat ini belum mencapai konsensus. Di sisi lain, istilah ‘emerging powers’ juga dikritik sebagai istilah yang kurang bermakna secara konseptual, karena sering kali menggunakan parameter dari teori ‘middle power’ klasik secara sembarangan. Melalui metode studi pustaka, penelitian ini mengkaji bagaimana perdebatan seputar definisi ‘middle powers’ berkembang, bagaimana istilah ‘emerging powers’ muncul dan kerap disamakan dengan istilah ‘middle power’, serta bagaimana studi terbaru berusaha mereformulasikan ‘emerging powers’ melalui pendekatan yang lebih dinamis, kontekstual, dan berbasis narasi. Studi ini menekankan pentingnya batasan konseptual yang lebih jelas untuk meningkatkan ketepatan analisis akademik dan relevansi kebijakan dalam memahami peran negara di tengah dinamika sistem internasional yang terus berubah. Kata-kata Kunci: Middle Power, Emerging Powers, Analisa Kebijakan Luar Negeri, Politik Internasional, Sistem Internasional