Villages have less development than cities because villages have bigger problems such as higher poverty rates, lower health, lower human resources, facilities and infrastructure that are more difficult to reach than cities. Therefore we need the concept of sustainable village development. In sustainable development, the aspect of development is not only aimed at present society but also society in the future. Before making the concept of sustainable village development, so that village development in a city/regency/district area is conceptualized evenly, decision support is needed to identify underdeveloped villages. Some indicators villages or underdeveloped regions mostly related to the survey of Potensi Desa activities by BPS from 1980 to 2014 continually participated. Related to that conditions, criteria obtained underdeveloped villages by DPU and indicator data PODES by BPS, it can be applied on Decision Making System. In this research selected case studies are census data from Potensi Desa by BPS in Magetan. This system uses SMARTER (Simple Multi-Attribute Rating Technique Exploiting Ranks) methods as the calculation of the weights to the criteria and ORESTE methods used for the rankings of underdeveloped villages. In this system SMARTER methods using a weighting formula Rank Order Centroid (ROC) that is proportional weighting which reflects the distance and the priority of each criteria appropriately. Furthermore, the ranking process using Oreste methods by three main stages that is Projection Matrix position, Ranking of projections and Agegration of Global Ranking. Testing of this system, which one is changing the parameters of Oreste (α value) and obtained compatibility reach 91.06% of accuracy to the experts data of underdeveloped villages from the BPS Magetan by the number 100% alternative data with value 0:01 of alpha