Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 3 Documents
Search

Kontroversi Penyembelihan Ismail-Ishak sebagai Kurban Abraham: Studi Komparatif Al-Qur'an dan Bibel Azwar Sani; Mumtaz Ibnu Yasa
Ushuluna: Jurnal Ilmu Ushuluddin Vol. 10 No. 1 (2024)
Publisher : Faculty of Ushuluddin UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15408/ushuluna.v10i1.37034

Abstract

Abstrak: Penyembelihan Ismail dan Ishak sebagai kurban Abraham menjadi topik yang kontroversial dalam agama Islam dan Kristen. Penelitian ini menggunakan metode analisis komparatif untuk membandingkan pandangan kedua agama tentang kisah ini. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengidentifikasi perspektif yang berbeda dalam kedua agama dan untuk menganalisis kesamaan dan perbedaan antara pandangan agama Islam dan Kristen dalam menanggapi kontroversi ini. Penelitian ini akan mengarah pada tiga tujuan, yaitu mengkaji pandangan agama Islam tentang kisah penyembelihan Ismail, menguji pandangan agama Kristen mengenai penyembelihan Ishak, dan membandingkan keduanya serta menganalisis perbedaan dan kesamaannya. Penelitian ini berfokus pada perbedaan interpretasi antara Islam dan Kristen tentang putra yang disembelih dan tujuan dari perintah Allah kepada Ibrahim untuk menyembelih putranya. Penelitian ini menggunakan sumber informasi yang bermutu, termasuk ayat-ayat Al-Qur'an dan Al-Kitab dari para ulama agama Islam dan tokoh agama Kristen yang terkemuka. Melalui hasil penelitian, dapat disimpulkan bahwa meskipun terdapat perbedaan interpretasi antara Islam dan Kristen bahkan agama islam itu sendiri tentang penyembelihan putra Abraham, kedua agama ini sama-sama menghargai pentingnya pengorbanan Nabi Ibrahim dan kesetiaannya pada Allah. Hasil dari penelitian ini dapat memberikan kontribusi positif dalam mengatasi kontroversi yang terkait dengan kisah penyembelihan Ismail atau Ishak sebagai kurban Abraham dan memperkuat hubungan antar umat beragama. Kata Kunci: Al-Qur'an dan Bible, Kontroversi, Komparasi, Kurban Abraham, Penyembelihan Abstract: The dispute over the sacrifice of Ismail and Ishak as Abraham's (Ibrahim's) offering is a controversial topic in both Islam and Christianity. This study employs a comparative analysis method to compare the two religions' views on the story. The study aims to identify different perspectives in both religions and analyze the similarities and differences in their responses to the controversy. The research will focus on three objectives: first, to examine the Islamic perspective of the sacrifice of Ismail as Abraham's offering in the Quran; second, to test the Christian perspective of the sacrifice of Ishak as Abraham's offering in the Bible; third, to compare the two religions' perspectives and analyze the differences and similarities between the sacrifice of Ismail and Ishak as Abraham's offering in the Quran and Bible. The study focuses on the different interpretations between Islam and Christianity regarding the son who was sacrificed and the purpose of Allah's command to Abraham to sacrifice his son. The study uses credible sources of information, including verses from the Quran and Bible from renowned Islamic scholars and Christian religious leaders. The findings show that despite the different interpretations between Islam and Christianity, and even within Islam itself, regarding the sacrifice of Abraham's son, both religions value the significance of the sacrifice of Prophet Ibrahim and his devotion to Allah. The research results could make a positive contribution in addressing the controversy surrounding the sacrifice of Ismail or Ishak as Abraham's offering and strengthening interfaith relations. Keywords: Quran and Bible. Controversy, Comparison, Abraham's Sacrifice, Slaughter
POLEMIC ON THE BASIS OF THE HIZBUT-TAHRIR CALIPHATE SYSTEM: STUDY OF THE INTERPRETATION OF QS. AL-MAIDAH: 48-49 AND QS. AN-NISSA: 59 Azwar Sani
Mafatih Vol. 5 No. 1 (2025): Mafatih: Jurnal Ilmu Al-Qur'an dan Tafsir
Publisher : IAT IAIN Pontianak

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.24260/mafatih.v5i1.3157

Abstract

This study aims to critically examine the polemics surrounding the conceptual foundations of the caliphate system advocated by Hizbut Tahrir, with particular emphasis on the perspective of Taqiyuddin an-Nabhani. The background of this research is rooted in the intensifying and ongoing debates regarding the relevance and urgency of implementing the caliphate system in the contemporary global context, which frequently generate controversy, especially in Indonesia as a state founded upon the ideology of Pancasila. Methodologically, this study employs an interpretative analysis using the contextual approach developed by Abdullah Saeed, while also conducting a comparative examination of the perspectives of classical and contemporary Qur’anic exegetes (mufassirīn) in interpreting key Qur’anic verses, particularly QS Al-Maidah 48-49 and QS An-Nisa 59. This approach seeks to uncover the dynamics of interpretation that extend beyond textual analysis by incorporating the historical and         socio-cultural contexts in which the verses are understood. The findings indicate that Hizbut Tahrir regards the caliphate system as the sole normative solution to addressing various challenges faced by humanity, based on the assumption that Islamic teachings constitute a comprehensive and immutable legal system. However, this perspective has generated considerable debate among a number of exegetes, who argue that the Qur’an does not explicitly mandate the implementation of a single, specific form of governance within a state. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengkaji secara kritis polemik mengenai landasan konseptual sistem khilafah yang diusung oleh Hizbut Tahrir, dengan penekanan khusus pada perspektif Taqiyuddin an-Nabhani. Latar belakang penelitian ini berangkat dari intensitas perdebatan yang terus berkembang terkait relevansi dan urgensi penerapan sistem khilafah dalam konteks global kontemporer, yang kerap memunculkan kontroversi, khususnya di Indonesia sebagai negara yang berlandaskan ideologi Pancasila. Secara metodologis, penelitian ini menggunakan analisis interpretatif dengan pendekatan kontekstual yang dikembangkan oleh Abdullah Saeed, serta melakukan komparasi dengan pemikiran para mufassir klasik dan kontemporer dalam menafsirkan ayat-ayat Al-Qur’an, khususnya QS Al-Maidah 48-49 dan QS An-Nisa 59. Pendekatan ini bertujuan untuk mengungkap dinamika penafsiran yang tidak hanya bersifat tekstual, tetapi juga mempertimbangkan konteks historis dan sosial yang melatarbelakanginya. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa Hizbut Tahrir memandang sistem khilafah sebagai satu-satunya solusi normatif dalam menyelesaikan berbagai persoalan umat manusia, yang didasarkan pada asumsi bahwa ajaran Islam merupakan sistem hukum yang bersifat komprehensif dan tidak dapat diubah. Namun demikian, pandangan ini menimbulkan polemik di kalangan sejumlah mufassir, yang berargumen bahwa Al-Qur’an tidak secara eksplisit menetapkan kewajiban penerapan satu bentuk sistem pemerintahan tertentu dalam suatu negara.
Kritik Terhadap Penggunaan Metode Penafsiran Literal dalam Tafsir Al-Qur’an Azwar Sani
Journal al Irfani : Ilmu al Qur'an dan Tafsir Vol 5 No 1 (2024): Al Irfani
Publisher : STAI Darul Kamal NW Kembang Kerang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.51700/irfani.v5i1.606

Abstract

This research aims to criticize the use of literal interpretation methods in the interpretation of the Quran and offer contextual interpretation as an alternative method of interpretation. The study analyzed the history of the use of literal interpretation methods in the interpretation of the Quran, the characteristics of literal interpretation methods, the weaknesses of literal interpretation methods, and the impacts of using literal interpretation methods. The method used in this study was qualitative with a literature study approach. Data was collected through a literature study of books, journals, and related articles. Then, data analysis was conducted using a qualitative descriptive analysis method. The results of the study show that the use of literal interpretation methods in the interpretation of the Quran still lacks attention to the historical and social context when writing verses, and produces a rigid and limited understanding of the Quranic text. The excessive use of literal interpretation methods can also lead to conflicts among Muslims. The impacts of using literal interpretation methods include producing a rigid understanding of religion, neglecting the development of times and the needs of Muslims, and not paying enough attention to social justice values in the Quran. As an alternative, contextual interpretation is offered as a method that pays more attention to the historical, social, and cultural context when writing verses in the Quran. In conclusion, this research shows that the use of literal interpretation methods in the interpretation of the Quran has many weaknesses and negative impacts, so it is necessary to consider using alternative methods such as contextual interpretation.