The minimum age requirement for marriage under Malaysian Islamic family law provides the Syariah Court with discretion to permit underage marriages. However, this discretionary authority has rarely been examined in terms of how judges actually reason in reaching their decisions, rather than merely examining the content of those decisions. This study aims to explain the legal requirements and procedures for applications to marry at a young age, the considerations the Syariah Court of the Federal Territory of Putrajaya uses in granting or rejecting such applications, and the Islamic family law perspective underlying these regulations. The study employed a descriptive qualitative approach with an empirical juridical design. The study collected data through interviews with judges, registrars, and Syarie officers at the Syariah Court of the Federal Territory of Putrajaya, supplemented by observation and official documentation. The data were analyzed through data reduction, data presentation, and conclusion drawing. The findings reveal three main points. First, the application procedure is multilayered and selective, as reflected in the very low number of applications, which tended to decline in Putrajaya between 2021 and 2025. Second, judges do not regard age as the sole measure of marriage eligibility; rather, they integrate philosophical, juridical, sociological, psychological, and public-interest considerations within a comprehensive decision-making framework. Third, the minimum marriage age stipulated in the Islamic Family Law (Federal Territories) Act 1984 is understood as a form of contemporary ijtihad that is consistent with the objectives of Islamic law (maqasid al-shariah), rather than a deviation from them. These findings demonstrate that the effectiveness of resolving underage marriage applications cannot be measured solely by administrative compliance, but also by the depth of judicial reasoning in assessing the long-term welfare and interests of the parties involved.