This article seeks to explore the debate between two groups of Indonesian Hadhramis (BÄ â€˜Alawi and non-Sayyid) concerning the maulid celebration. It is based on a qualitative research study. The data was collected through a combination of library research and field study. The fieldwork was completed in Surakarta by observing the maulid celebration of the BÄ â€˜Alawi community in the city. The study results show the debate between the Sayyid and non-Sayyid communities surrounding the maulid has occurred since the early 20th century and continues until today. The first group, also known as the BÄ â€˜Alawi, have consistently supported the maulid practice since the early 20th century, starting with the establishment of Jamiat Khair to several BÄ â€˜Alawi preachers such as the ones in the Riyadh Mosque in Surakarta that are explained in this text. Regarding the second group, the maulid is promoted by the Al-Irsyad faction, which do not condemn the maulid but only criticize some practices within the celebration they regard as bid’a. In the present day, Al-Irsyad is separated into two groups: Al-Irsyad Al-Islamiyah and the Salafis of Perhimpunan al-Irsyad. This article finds that the former preserves the old stance of the organization regarding the maulid. However, the latter has a stricter teaching on the maulid, stating it is bid’a and recommends its members and followers not to practice it.
                        
                        
                        
                        
                            
                                Copyrights © 2020