Employee promotion requires a structured evaluation when several criteria contain gradual or linguistic boundaries. This study compares Fuzzy Tahani and Fuzzy Tsukamoto in a decision support model for employee-promotion recommendations. To ensure a controlled comparison, both methods use the same five criteria, domains, and membership functions. Because the source report does not contain official employee-assessment scores, the computational mechanism is verified using five anonymized test alternatives rather than actual personnel decisions. Fuzzy Tahani combines membership degrees through a fuzzy query and produces a fire-strength score, whereas Fuzzy Tsukamoto activates IF-THEN rules with monotonic consequents and produces a crisp value through weighted defuzzification. The test data produce the same ranking for both methods: A2, A5, A1, A3, and A4, yielding a Spearman rank correlation of 1.00. Despite identical rankings, the output behavior differs: Tahani is highly sensitive to the weakest mandatory condition under the MIN operator, while Tsukamoto aggregates contributions from multiple active rules. The results indicate methodological consistency on the test data but must be validated with official institutional data before operational use.
Copyrights © 2023