INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LANGUAGE PEDAGOGY
Vol. 5 No. 2 (2025)

Process-Based vs. Product-Based Approaches in Teaching Academic Writing: A Comparative Study

Asrifan, Andi (Unknown)
Luís Miguel Oliveira de Barros Cardoso (Unknown)
K. J. Vargheese (Unknown)
Raveenthiran Vivekanantharasa (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
02 Nov 2025

Abstract

Academic writing is essential in higher education, especially for English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners who need to adhere to academic and publication standards. This research was carried out in the English Education Department of a public university in Indonesia, involving 40 undergraduate students aged 19 to 22 with intermediate English competence. Employing a mixed-methods quasi-experimental design, two intact classrooms were allocated distinct instructional methodologies during an eight-week period: one engaged in process-based teaching, while the other participated in product-based teaching. Quantitative analysis utilizing paired and independent sample t-tests indicated that the process-based group exhibited substantially larger improvement (M = 78.65, SD = 4.88) compared to the product-based group (M = 73.40, SD = 5.12), t(38) = 3.17, p < 0.01. The process-oriented approach also resulted in enhanced coherence, vocabulary, and structure. Qualitative findings from student interviews and reflections corroborated these outcomes, indicating enhanced engagement, motivation, and confidence among process-oriented learners. The results demonstrate that recursive writing techniques and iterative feedback significantly promote enduring writing advancement. The study advocates for the incorporation of process- and product-oriented components to improve EFL academic writing instruction in Indonesian higher education.

Copyrights © 2025






Journal Info

Abbrev

ijolp

Publisher

Subject

Humanities Education Languange, Linguistic, Communication & Media Social Sciences

Description

International Journal of Language Pedagogy (IJoLP) is an international peer-reviewed, scientific and open-access journal in language education. The aim is to publish conceptual and research articles that explore the application of any language in teaching and the everyday experience of language in ...