Al-'Adl
Vol. 18 No. 2 (2025): Al-'Adl

The Vicarious Liability of Adults in Juvenile Crimes: An Analysis of the Representation in the Series Juvenile Justice from the Perspective of Indonesian Criminal Law

Prayudi (Unknown)
Purwanda, Sunardi (Unknown)
Sabir, Muhammad (Unknown)
Tijjang, Bakhtiar (Unknown)
Mannan, Khaerul (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
31 Jul 2025

Abstract

This study examines how the Netflix series Juvenile Justice (2022) represents the involvement of adults in offences committed by children, and whether that representation supports extending criminal liability to adults through a vicarious liability model under Indonesian criminal law. The question matters because juvenile justice debates in Indonesia and South Korea remain centred on the child offender, while the adults who neglect, abuse, use, or shield children largely stay outside the frame of criminal attribution. the study combines normative legal research (statutory, conceptual, and case approaches) with a qualitative scene analysis of all ten episodes, coded by type of adult involvement and by the legal response depicted. Four recurring patterns emerge, namely parental absence and neglect, active violence within caregiving relationships, abuse of position and concealment, and institutional failure. The series also shows a consistent asymmetry in which children carry formal sanctions while adults whose conduct shaped the offence face weak or no criminal consequences. Read against Articles 20, 36, and 37 of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code and Article 76I of the Child Protection Law, a pure vicarious liability model collides with the culpability principle, but a limited model is defensible when four cumulative conditions are met: a legal duty of supervision, factual control, a causal contribution to the risk, and at least negligence. The findings support specific statutory rules implementing Article 37(b), wider use of the “allowing” offence in child exploitation cases, and mandatory guardian education within diversion. The study offers a doctrinal test for “limited vicarious liability” in juvenile cases and shows how popular legal culture can serve as a source of normative critique rather than mere illustration

Copyrights © 2025






Journal Info

Abbrev

al-adl

Publisher

Subject

Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice Social Sciences

Description

Jurnal Al-'Adl merupakan Jurnal Ilmiah yang diterbitkan oleh Fakultas Syariah IAIN Kendari. Al-'Adl secara spesifik mempublikasikan tulisan ilmiah baik naskah ilmiah maupun hasil penelitian yang berorientasi pada masalah hukum Islam dan pranata sosial serta kajian keislaman ...