El Midad: Jurnal Jurusan PGMI
Vol. 18 No. 1 (2026): El-Midad: Jurnal Jurusan PGMI

RETHINKING EDUCATIONAL MANAGERIALISM: A CRITICAL PARADIGM AS AN EPISTEMOLOGICAL COUNTERBALANCE IN CONTEMPORARY EDUCATION

Supriyadi Supriyadi (Universitas Bina Bangsa)
Nuryati Nuryati (Universitas Bina Bangsa)
Nurul Dewi hayati (Universitas Bina Bangsa)
Masitoh Masitoh (Universitas Bina Bangsa)
Siti Nur Asiah (Universitas Bina Bangsa)



Article Info

Publish Date
08 Mar 2026

Abstract

The growing dominance of educational managerialism in contemporary education has reshaped governance practices by emphasizing efficiency, accountability, standardization, and performance measurement. While managerial approaches have contributed to administrative order and organizational control, they are increasingly criticized for narrowing the epistemological and ethical foundations of education. This study aims to examine educational managerialism as a critical epistemological paradigm and to position the critical paradigm as an epistemological counterbalance within contemporary education. Employing a qualitative critical literature review, this study analyzes peer-reviewed journal articles and scholarly books published between 2020 and 2024 using a critical epistemological framework informed by critical social theory. The analysis focuses on uncovering the epistemological assumptions, ideological orientations, and power relations embedded in managerial knowledge and governance practices. The findings reveal that educational managerialism privileges instrumental rationality and claims of value neutrality, which function to legitimize performance-based governance while marginalizing reflective, ethical, and contextual forms of educational knowledge. In contrast, the critical paradigm offers a reflective framework that challenges these assumptions and reorients educational management toward democratic participation, social justice, and human emancipation. Rather than rejecting management outright, this study demonstrates that the critical paradigm can function as a corrective and balancing epistemological framework, enabling more humanistic and ethically grounded approaches to educational governance. This article contributes to international debates on critical educational management by advancing an epistemological synthesis that integrates critique with constructive transformation.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

elmidad

Publisher

Subject

Religion Education Social Sciences Other

Description

El Midad: Jurnal Jurusan PGMI with e-ISSN 2656-4289; p-ISSN 2087-8389mainly focuses on learning in Primary schools teacher education or primary school. Detailed scopes of articles accepted for submission to Jurnal are: Learning Theory Curriculum and Technology in Education School Management in ...