International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE)
Vol 15, No 3: June 2026

Evaluation of oral tradition-based reading instruction on secondary students reading competence

Teófilo Félix Valentín Melgarejo (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Clodoaldo Ramos Pando (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Pablo Lolo Valentín Melgarejo (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Fidel Alberto García Yale (Hermilio Valdizán National University)
William Cesar Santos Hinostroza (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Rober Wesmel Sánchez Trinidad (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Ulises Espinoza Apolinario (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Rosa Luz Gómez Segura (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Tito Armando Rivera Espinoza (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
José Rovino Alvarez López (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Julio César Carhuaricra Meza (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)
Flaviano Armando Zenteno Ruiz (Daniel Alcides Carrión National University)



Article Info

Publish Date
01 Jun 2026

Abstract

Reading competence is a developmental and multidimensional construct that is often evaluated through mean score comparisons that may obscure structural learning changes. This study examined the effectiveness of a culturally grounded oral tradition–based intervention on primary students’ reading competence in Pasco, Peru. A quantitative quasi-experimental pretest–posttest design with a control group was implemented using intact classrooms (experimental n=19; control n=14; N=33). The eight-week intervention integrated local myths, legends, and folktales into guided reading, inferential questioning, and evaluative discussion activities. Reading competence was assessed using narrative texts scored with an analytic rubric classifying students into four ordered achievement levels (initial, in process, expected, and outstanding). Data were analyzed using ordinal mobility analysis, distributional dominance testing, and dynamic-systems indicators. Results showed complete structural stability in the control group, whereas 89.5% of students in the experimental group demonstrated upward mobility and all reached expected or outstanding levels at posttest. These findings indicate that culturally responsive oral-tradition instruction can produce substantial structural improvements in reading competence. This study contributes to educational evaluation by demonstrating how ordinal mobility and dynamic-systems indicators reveal instructional effects that may remain hidden in traditional mean-based analyses.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

IJERE

Publisher

Subject

Education

Description

The International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE) is an interdisciplinary publication of original research and writing on education which publishes papers to international audiences of educational researchers. The IJERE aims to provide a forum for scholarly understanding of ...