Journal of Vocational Education Studies (JOVES)
Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026): Vol 9 No 1

Discrepancy in Industrial Acceptance Between Vocational High School (SMK) and Bachelor's Degree (S1) Graduates: a Combined Analysis of Secondary Data and Industry Perspectives

Ary Maulana Muaripin (Universitas Islam Bunga Bangsa Cirebon)
Muaripin Muaripin (Universitas Islam Bunga Bangsa Cirebon)



Article Info

Publish Date
23 May 2026

Abstract

This study examines the employment acceptance gap between SMK (vocational high school) and S1 (university) graduates across industrial sectors in Indonesia. BPS data shows that the open unemployment rate for SMK graduates is higher than that of S1 graduates, even though SMK is designed to produce job-ready workers. This mixed-method study uses secondary data from BPS and the Ministry of Manpower, as well as semi-structured interviews with five HRD practitioners from manufacturing, services, logistics, retail, and technology sectors. The findings indicate that the gap is caused by skills mismatch, low soft skills among SMK graduates, and limited industry linkages. In contrast, S1 graduates are considered more adaptable in cognitive and communication skills, although not always in technical skills. The study highlights the need for vocational education reform, including curriculum improvement, industry-based competency certification, and stronger collaboration between government, schools, and industries to improve SMK graduates’ employability and reduce the unemployment gap.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

joves

Publisher

Subject

Education Engineering Social Sciences Other

Description

The Journal invites original articles and not simultaneously submitted to another journal or conference. The journal explores vocationalism in learning and efforts to address employability within the curriculum, together with coverage of innovative themes and initiatives within vocational education ...