Teras Jurnal
Vol 16 No 2 (2026): Teras Jurnal (September 2026)

A Analisis Perbandingan Respons Dinamis Struktur Boat Landing Offshore Platform Menggunakan Metode Working Stress Design dan Load and Resistance Factor Design

Yovi Chandra (Jurusan Teknik Sipil Universitas Malikussaleh)
Fadhliani Fadhliani (Jurusan Teknik Sipil Universitas Malikussaleh)
Nur Wijaya Ningsih (Jurusan Teknik Sipil Universitas Malikussaleh)



Article Info

Publish Date
10 Jul 2026

Abstract

Abstrak   Boat landing merupakan struktur tambahan pada offshore platform untuk sandaran kapal yang mampu menahan beban dinamis lingkungan laut dan potensi tubrukan. Untuk meminimalisir risiko kegagalan, evaluasi struktural dilakukan meliputi analisis in-place (statis), dinamis, dan fatigue (kelelahan beban berulang). Analisis ini membandingkan metode Working Stress Design (WSD) dan Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) menggunakan pemodelan SACS melalui time history analysis untuk parameter displacement, velocity, dan acceleration. Hasil Analisis in-place menunjukkan semua elemen memenuhi batas unity check. Pada beban Kondisi lingkungan, LRFD menghasilkan respons dinamis ± 2% lebih besar dari WSD dan pada tumbukan kapal, LRFD memberi displacement dan acceleration lebih besar (2% dan 0,1%), meskipun velocity 0,3% lebih rendah. Analisis fatigue mendeteksi empat member gagal mencapai target umur rencana. Kesimpulannya, metode LRFD menghasilkan respons dinamis 2% lebih konservatif dibanding WSD, tetapi seluruh elemen tetap aman secara statik. LRFD lebih direkomendasikan karena memberikan margin keamanan optimal tanpa over-design, dengan syarat empat elemen kritis diperkuat agar memenuhi target umur lelah (fatigue)   Kata kunci: Boat Landing Offshore Platform, In-place, Respons Dinamis, Fatigue, WSD, LRFD.   Abstract   A boat landing is an auxiliary structure on an offshore platform that facilitates vessel berthing and must withstand dynamic environmental loads and potential ship impacts. This study evaluates and compares the structural performance of boat landing structures designed using the Working Stress Design (WSD) and Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) methods through in-place, dynamic, and fatigue analyses conducted in SACS. Dynamic responses were assessed using time history analysis based on displacement, velocity, and acceleration. The results indicate that all structural members satisfy the unity check requirements under both design approaches. Under environmental loading, LRFD produces dynamic responses up to 2% higher than WSD. In ship impact scenarios, LRFD yields slightly greater displacement and acceleration responses, while velocity is marginally lower. Fatigue analysis reveals that four structural members fail to meet the target design life. Overall, LRFD provides a more conservative dynamic response and is recommended, provided that strengthening is applied to the identified critical members.   Keywords: Boat Landing Offshore Platform, In-place Analysis, Dynamic Response, Fatigue, WSD, LRFD

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

teras

Publisher

Subject

Civil Engineering, Building, Construction & Architecture Engineering Environmental Science

Description

Teras Jurnal is a journal that communicates the results of research within the scope of civil engineering and scientific development as well as aspects of practitioners. The process of manuscript submission is open throughout the year. All submitted manuscript will be screened with double-blind peer ...