Journal of Educational Research and Evaluation
Vol 10 No 2 (2026): May

Situational Judgment Tests: Research Trends and Conceptual Foundations for Developing a Moral Competence Assessment for Teachers

Fikri Nurcahya (Graduate School, State University of Jakarta, Indonesia)
Wardani Rahayu (Graduate School, State University of Jakarta, Indonesia)
Anan Sutisna (Graduate School, State University of Jakarta, Indonesia)
Dinny Devi Triana (Graduate School, State University of Jakarta, Indonesia)
Riyan Arthur (Graduate School, State University of Jakarta, Indonesia)
Irwanto (Chemistry Education, State University of Jakarta, Indonesia)



Article Info

Publish Date
25 May 2026

Abstract

This study aimed to map the development of Situational Judgment Test (SJT) research over the last decade and to synthesize the literature concerning the use of SJTs in teacher-related contexts and the assessment of moral constructs. The research employed two complementary approaches: a bibliometric analysis of 264 Scopus-indexed articles published between 2016 and 2025, and a literature review of studies on teacher SJTs and moral SJTs that met the established inclusion criteria. The bibliometric findings revealed a steady growth in SJT research, with dominant themes centered on decision-making and education, whereas morality did not emerge as a prominent research topic. This finding highlights a theoretical gap, given that decision-making in educational practice inherently involves moral considerations. The literature review demonstrated that teacher SJTs are effective in assessing social-emotional and pedagogical competencies, while moral SJTs are capable of capturing processes of moral disengagement. However, no existing instrument has systematically integrated both dimensions. The synthesis of the two analyses suggests that a conceptual foundation for the development of a teacher moral SJT already exists, yet it has not been operationalized in a systematic manner. The findings further indicate the need for more contextualized moral assessment tools to address the challenges of teaching practice in Indonesia and underscore their relevance to assessment systems within the Pancasila Ideology Development Education and Training Program (Diklat PIP). This study highlights the urgency of developing a teacher moral SJT and proposes an initial framework that may support the assessment needs of Diklat PIP within the teaching profession.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

JERE

Publisher

Subject

Humanities Education Public Health Social Sciences Other

Description

Journal of Educational Research and Evaluation (JERE) is an interdisciplinary publication of original research and writing on education which publishes papers to international audiences of educational researchers. The JERE aims to provide a forum for scholarly understanding of the field of education ...