Syariah: Jurnal Hukum dan Pemikiran
Vol 26 No 1 (2026): Contemporary Transformations of Islamic Law: Governance, Justice, Family, and Su

Reconstructing Indonesia's Bipartite Labor Dispute Resolution through Customary Bedamai: A Legal Pluralism Perspective

Wahyu Utami (Universitas Achmad Yani Banjarmasin)
Yogabakti Adipradana Setiawan (Universitas Achmad Yani Banjarmasin)



Article Info

Publish Date
11 Aug 2026

Abstract

The formal bipartite mechanism in Indonesia's labor dispute resolution, governed by Law No. 2 of 2004, is characterized by rigidity, adversarial dynamics, and a frequent lack of good faith, creating a systemic bottleneck in industrial relations that undermines both worker welfare and enterprise productivity. Integrating the customary Bedamai approach, rooted in Banjar adat traditions, offers a restorative, consensus-driven solution to this persistent controversy. Through the analytical lens of legal pluralism, a critical gap exists between the positivist state labor law framework and the sociological need for harmonious, culturally resonant dispute resolution mechanisms that reflect Indonesia's diverse legal traditions. This study aims to reconstruct the formal bipartite mechanism by integrating the bedamai customary approach to achieve more effective and harmonious dispute settlements that honor both statutory requirements and indigenous values. The research employs a purely normative legal method utilizing statutory, conceptual, and cultural approaches, analyzing primary and secondary legal materials without empirical fieldwork, thereby focusing on doctrinal analysis and legal reconstruction. The findings reveal that bedamai fundamentally shifts the paradigm from adversarial rights-claiming to restorative relationship-building, emphasizing communal harmony over individual victory. A reconstructed "Bipartite-bedamai Integration Model" is formulated, embedding customary consensus-building and community facilitation into the statutory negotiation phase while maintaining legal enforceability. The study concludes that legal pluralism must move beyond sociological observation toward normative integration, recommending specific amendments to Law No. 2 of 2004 to formally recognize customary mechanisms as a valid, parallel, or preliminary bipartite process

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

syariah

Publisher

Subject

Humanities Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

Syariah specializes on Law and Islamic law, and is intended to communicate original research and current issues on the subject. This journal warmly welcomes contributions from scholars of related ...