Religious Education (PAI), yet both are difficult to develop when instruction remains dominated by one-directional lecturing. This article reports an ex post facto quantitative study examining the effect of the active debate method on tolerance attitudes and critical thinking among Culinary Class X students at SMKN 1 Dlanggu. The population consisted of 106 students, with a sample of 35 respondents determined through proportional random sampling. Data were collected using a five-point Likert questionnaire that had passed validity (Product Moment correlation) and reliability (Cronbach's Alpha) testing, then analyzed using simple linear regression with IBM SPSS Statistics 26. The results show that active debate has a positive and significant effect on tolerance attitudes, evidenced by a t-count of 9.262, greater than the t-table value of 2.030, at a significance level of 0.000. The regression equation Y1 = 16.233 + 0.733X with a coefficient of determination (R Square) of 0.722 indicates that active debate contributes 72.2 percent to tolerance attitudes. A similar effect was found for critical thinking, with a t-count of 8.047 greater than the t-table value of 2.030 at a significance of 0.000, a regression equation of Y2 = 23.764 + 0.821X, and an R Square of 0.662, or a 66.2 percent contribution. These findings reinforce the argument that active debate can simultaneously unite students' cognitive and affective development, and it is therefore recommended as an alternative method for PAI instruction, particularly for vocational students who will later require strong communication skills and openness in the workplace Sikap toleransi dan critical thinking merupakan dua kompetensi yang idealnya tumbuh bersamaan dalam pembelajaran Pendidikan Agama Islam (PAI), namun keduanya sulit berkembang optimal apabila pembelajaran masih didominasi ceramah satu arah. Artikel ini melaporkan hasil penelitian kuantitatif ex post facto yang menguji pengaruh metode debat aktif terhadap sikap toleransi dan critical thinking murid kelas X Kuliner SMKN 1 Dlanggu. Populasi penelitian berjumlah 106 murid, dengan sampel 35 responden yang ditentukan melalui proportional random sampling. Data dijaring lewat angket skala Likert lima poin yang telah diuji validitas (korelasi Product Moment) dan reliabilitas (Cronbach's Alpha), kemudian dianalisis dengan regresi linear sederhana berbantuan IBM SPSS Statistics 26. Hasil analisis menunjukkan bahwa debat aktif berpengaruh positif dan signifikan terhadap sikap toleransi, dibuktikan melalui nilai t hitung 9,262 lebih besar dari t tabel 2,030 pada signifikansi 0,000. Persamaan regresi Y1 = 16,233 + 0,733X dengan koefisien determinasi (R Square) 0,722 menunjukkan kontribusi debat aktif sebesar 72,2 persen terhadap sikap toleransi. Pengaruh serupa juga ditemukan pada critical thinking, dengan t hitung 8,047 lebih besar dari t tabel 2,030 pada signifikansi 0,000, persamaan regresi Y2 = 23,764 + 0,821X, dan R Square sebesar 0,662 atau kontribusi 66,2 persen. Temuan ini memperkuat argumen bahwa debat aktif dapat menyatukan pengembangan kognitif dan afektif murid sekaligus, sehingga direkomendasikan sebagai alternatif metode pembelajaran PAI, khususnya bagi murid program keahlian yang kelak dituntut memiliki kecakapan komunikasi dan keterbukaan sikap tinggi di dunia kerja.
Copyrights © 2026