This study reconceptualizes cohesion in EFL writing by moving beyond frequency-based descriptions toward a discourse-functional evaluation of cohesive device use. Drawing on Halliday and Hasan’s (1976) framework and extending insights from contemporary applied linguistics, the study investigates the typology, distribution, and functional appropriateness of cohesive devices in argumentative essays written by Indonesian undergraduate students of English Language and Literature (ELL) program. A mixed-methods, corpus-informed design was employed, integrating quantitative frequency analysis with qualitative discourse evaluation. The dataset comprises thirty argumentative essays analyzed using Key Word in Context (KWIC) concordance and expert-validated coding procedures. Findings indicate a strong reliance on lexical repetition and basic reference forms, alongside systematic underuse of substitution and ellipsis. Although the overall rate of grammatical accuracy is high, recurrent misapplications of conjunctions and referential devices disrupt logical relations and weaken argumentative coherence. These results highlight that cohesion in EFL among Indonesian ELL students’ writing remains predominantly surface-oriented, with limited functional control at the discourse level. The study contributes to applied linguistics by challenging the adequacy of frequency-based cohesion models and proposing a discourse-functional framework for evaluating cohesion in L2 writing. Pedagogically, it offers evidence-based implications for developing cohesion-focused instruction that enhances rhetorical precision and argumentative clarity.
Copyrights © 2026