Religious moderation in Islamic education has been widely studied through curriculum, institutional culture, and teacher modeling, yet little attention has been paid to how fiqh disagreement (ikhtilaf) is pedagogically managed as a resource for cultivating moderate religious dispositions. This qualitative case study examines how ikhtilaf is handled in contemporary fiqh learning at Jarinabi Pesantren, Sabak Barat, Tanjung Jabung Timur, Jambi, Indonesia, drawing on semi-structured interviews with 17 participants (one Kiai, six ustaz, and ten santri), observation, and documentation, analyzed thematically. Findings reveal three interconnected themes: (1) negotiating fiqh differences through wasatiyyah, (2) contextualizing fiqh through dialogue and contemporary cases, and (3) dialogical pedagogy and teacher modeling. Rather than merely presenting differing legal opinions, teachers encourage students to examine evidence, understand the basis of disagreement, and avoid premature judgment. Dialogical engagement is reinforced through teachers’ modeling of respectful disagreement and the habituation of appropriate responses to differing views. Digital religious information poses an additional challenge, requiring pedagogical mediation to help students navigate fragmented interpretations. The study argues that ikhtilaf can function as a pedagogical resource for religious moderation when mediated through wasatiyyah, contextualized dialogue, and teacher modeling. This approach is grounded in the Qur’anic concept of ummatan wasatan (QS. Al-Baqarah [2]:143) and the fiqh distinction between ikhtilaf sa'igh and disagreement rooted in fanaticism, with adab al-ikhtilaf serving as its ethical framework. The findings reflect observed practices and reported experiences rather than measured long-term dispositional change.
Copyrights © 2025