First-grade students’ difficulty in understanding subtraction as a reduction in quantity indicates the need for concrete media that connect physical actions with mathematical symbols. This study aimed to develop and conduct a limited evaluation of a Counting Box in terms of feasibility, practicality, and descriptive effectiveness for subtraction learning. The study employed a Research and Development approach using the ADDIE model and a one-group pretest–posttest evaluation involving 24 first-grade students at MIN 6 Kota Medan. Data were collected through a teacher interview, documentation of initial learning scores, expert validation sheets, teacher and student response questionnaires, and 10-item pretest and posttest assessments. Quantitative data were analyzed using means, percentages, mastery rates, and individual N-Gain scores, while qualitative feedback guided product revision. The media expert awarded a mean score of 4.70 and the material expert 4.65, producing an overall mean of 4.68 in the highly feasible category. Teacher and student responses reached 98% and 93.6%, respectively, indicating high practicality. The mean score increased from 68.75 on the pretest to 92.92 on the posttest, a difference of 24.17 points, with a mean N-Gain of 0.83 in the high category. Fifteen students obtained high N-Gain and nine obtained moderate N-Gain. These findings provide descriptive evidence that the Counting Box is feasible and practical and is associated with improved subtraction performance. However, because the limited trial did not include a control group or inferential analysis, the improvement cannot be interpreted as a definitive causal effect.
Copyrights © 2026