Journal Education and Government Wiyata
Vol 4 No 4 (2026): November 2026

REFORMASI ARSITEKTUR MUSRENBANG DI TENGAH KOMPRESI FISKAL: ANALISIS AKAR MASALAH DAN ALTERNATIF KEBIJAKAN DI KOTA BITUNG

Ronny Nara Tumbelaka (Badan Perencanaan Pembangunan Daerah Kota Bitung, Bitung, Sulawesi Utara, Indonesia)



Article Info

Publish Date
02 Oct 2026

Abstract

Musrenbang, Indonesia's tiered participatory planning forum, is meant to ground local development plans in community needs, yet only a small share of its proposals reaches the final work plan and budget. This study traces the root cause of that aspiration-allocation gap in Bitung City and formulates a recommendation within the city's own authority. The gap is reframed as a failure of institutional architecture rather than of participation quality. The study applies qualitative policy analysis of regulations, three cycles of Musrenbang records, field observation, and the participatory budgeting literature. Problems are prioritized through an urgency, seriousness, and growth appraisal; causes are traced in two levels; and four alternatives are assessed with cross-checked feasibility criteria. The root cause is the absence of a binding norm that converges community proposals, council aspirations, and mayoral priorities through transparent, data-based scoring. A mayoral regulation establishing a convergent Musrenbang architecture is the most systemic option and needs no additional fiscal space under the 2026 transfer contraction.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

e-gov

Publisher

Subject

Education Social Sciences Other

Description

Journal Education And Government Wiyata adalah sebuah jurnal blind peer-review yang didedikasikan untuk publikasi hasil penelitian atau kajian literatur yang berkualitas dalam aspek Pendidikan dan Pemerintahan dan tidak terbatas secara implisit. Semua publikasi di Journal Education And Government ...