The Free Nutritional Meals (MBG) program is one of the Indonesian government's largest post-2024 social interventions and positions schools as a crucial arena for fulfilling the right to food and developing human capital. This article evaluates the MBG program for students in its second year of implementation by developing an integrative framework linking state responsibility, the social investment paradigm, implementation theory, William Dunn's policy evaluation criteria, and the Context–Input–Process–Product (CIPP) model. The research uses qualitative policy analysis and structured evidence synthesis of peer-reviewed articles, national nutrition surveys, MBG policy studies, and official documents through September 2026. The article's theoretical contribution is the concept of the 'state responsibility–social investment conversion chain': recognition of rights and resource allocation only yield social benefits if they are converted through implementation capacity, food security, equitable access, responsiveness, and credible outcome measurement. Results indicate that the MBG's normative and social investment rationales are strong, while causal evidence regarding the specific impacts of the Indonesian MBG on stunting, academic achievement, and anthropometric indicators remains limited. International literature provides stronger support for improving school meal participation, attendance, food security, and, in some contexts, learning achievement, but the magnitude of the effects varies. By 2026, implementation issues had shifted from a lack of guidelines to gaps in compliance, capacity, food safety, and consistency across regions. Therefore, evaluating the success of the MBG should not stop at the number of portions or beneficiaries. The article recommends independent outcome audits, strengthening SOP and hygiene compliance, equity-based monitoring, beneficiary feedback mechanisms, inclusive local food procurement, and quasi-experimental cost-effectiveness and impact evaluations.
Copyrights © 2026