Hukum dan Demokrasi (HD)
Vol 26 No 2 (2026): Hukum dan Demokrasi (HD)

Kompetensi Absolut dan Pendekatan Substance Over Form dalam Sengketa Hubungan Kerja Terselubung pada Putusan Mahkamah Agung Nomor 818 K/Pdt/2026

Nicholas Ruben Pudjisatia (Universitas Tarumanagara)
Dr. Imelda Martinelli S.H., M.Hum. (Universitas Tarumanagara)



Article Info

Publish Date
06 Oct 2026

Abstract

Judicial competence determines which court is authorized to examine a given dispute, divided into absolute competence and relative competence. Absolute competence is mandatory and non-derogable. This study examines Supreme Court Decision No. 818 K/Pdt/2026, in which a worker and a company disputed the character of two agreements titled “Cooperation Agreement for Professional Development Investment,” executed based on a pre-existing indefinite-term employment agreement (PKWTT). The District Court and High Court applied a claim-based test, holding the District Court retained absolute competence, and found the employee liable for wanprestasi. The Supreme Court reversed, applying a relationship-based test: notwithstanding the agreements’ title, their internal terminology identified the parties as employer and worker, rendering the true relationship one of employment falling within the Industrial Relations Court’s exclusive competence. Using a normative juridical method, this study finds the disparity across the three tiers methodological rather than factual, and concludes that the Supreme Court’s substance-over-form reasoning is doctrinally correct, consistent with the cumulative work-wages-command test and the doctrine of legal circumvention.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jhd

Publisher

Subject

Humanities Education Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice Social Sciences

Description

Hukum dan Demokrasi (HD) adalah Jurnal ilmiah dengan fokus dan skop ilmu hukum, hukum pidana, hukum perdata, politik dan demokrasi, hukum bisnis dan hukum lingkungan. Diterbitkan oleh Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Hukum (STIH) Prof Gayus Lumbuun. Jurnal ini diterbitkan empat kali dalam satu tahun yaitu pada ...