Purpose: This study examines how National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) contribute to military accountability and social protection in Africa, through a comparative analysis of Kenya, South Africa and Nigeria.Methodology: The study adopts a qualitative comparative case study design combining documentary analysis and structured focused comparison of constitutional provisions, legislation, institutional reports and international standards across five accountability dimensions.Results: All three countries possess formal legal foundations for independent human rights oversight of security institutions, yet substantial gaps exist between legal authority and practical accountability. Kenya provides explicit constitutional authority for monitoring national security organs, South Africa demonstrates extensive investigative and reporting powers alongside implementation delays, and Nigeria shows significant capacity for independent investigation through its Special Independent Investigative Panel on counter-insurgency operations, constrained by evidence-access barriers.Conclusions: Social protection within security governance requires an institutional chain linking independent investigation, evidence access, determination of responsibility, effective remedy and implementation monitoring, and the study proposes a seven-stage accountability framework to operationalise this chain.Limitations: The study relies on documentary sources rather than primary interviews with NHRI officials or affected communities, and the three cases cannot represent the full diversity of African security governance contexts.Contributions: The study offers an integrated conceptual bridge between military accountability and social protection literatures and a replicable comparative framework for evaluating NHRI effectiveness in security-sensitive environments.
Copyrights © 2026