This study aims to reconstruct a coherent epistemological foundation for constitutional justice that can strengthen the consistency, legitimacy, and accountability of constitutional adjudication. This normative legal research employs a conceptual and statutory approach, complemented by a case approach to examine the Court’s constitutional reasoning and interpretive practices. The study finds that the Court’s epistemological practice tends to combine legal positivism, substantive constitutionalism, and Pancasila-based reasoning without a sufficiently integrated methodological structure. A coherent reconstruction requires formal validity as the initial threshold, Pancasila as the substantive normative foundation, proportionality as a structured method for resolving conflicts between constitutional principles and rights, argumentative coherence across decisions, and explicit accountability for value choices. These elements should be institutionally incorporated into the Court’s adjudicative framework to ensure that interpretive flexibility remains subject to identifiable and reviewable standards. The reconstruction demonstrates that constitutional justice can accommodate both formal legality and substantive justice within a coherent epistemological framework, thereby reinforcing the Indonesian constitutional state based on law.
Copyrights © 2025