AL-THIQAH: Jurnal Ilmu Keislaman
Vol 9 No 2 (2026): Oktober

KOMPARASI EPISTEMOLOGI METODOLOGI TAFSIR MAUDUI AL-FARMAWI, AL-SADR, DAN AL-KUMI

Muhammad Fadhil Syahridho (Universitas PTIQ Jakarta)
M. Azfa Nashirul Hikam (Universitas PTIQ Jakarta)
Fahmia Nuha Tsabita (Universitas PTIQ Jakarta)
Muhammad Ahnaf Nabil (Al Azhar University Cairo)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Oct 2026

Abstract

Thematic exegesis (tafs?r mau????) has become a dominant method in contemporary Qur’anic studies, yet in Indonesia it tends to be applied by following al-Farmaw?’s steps mechanically, without considering how the methods differ in their stages and underlying assumptions. This article compares the interpretive stages in the thematic exegesis methodologies of ?Abd al-?ayy al-Farmaw?, Mu?ammad B?qir al-?adr, and A?mad al-Sayyid al-K?m?. It is a qualitative library-based study using a comparative-analytical approach. Each method’s stages are broken down into input, operation, and output, then aligned stage by stage and read through al-J?bir?’s framework of bay?n?, burh?n?, and ?irf?n? epistemology. The findings show that al-Farmaw? sets out seven steps. They move from determining the theme, through collecting and contextualizing the verses, to an integrated analysis that culminates in coherence. Al-K?m? follows five steps with two distinctive features. He gathers the relevant ?ad?ths from the outset, and he resolves apparent contradictions between verses before interpretation begins, while also attending to the central purpose of the s?rah. Al-?adr reverses the direction in four steps. He first identifies a problem arising from reality and then masters human thought on that problem. He next engages the Qur’an in dialogue through istin??q, and finally formulates a Qur’anic theory and tests it back against reality. The first two methods rely on bay?n? reasoning, with coherence as their criterion of truth. Al-?adr combines bay?n? and burh?n? reasoning, with correspondence and pragmatic criteria. This article proposes a dialogical-procedural synthesis model. It places al-?adr’s reality-oriented stages at the beginning and the end, and the textual stages of al-Farmaw? and al-K?m? in the middle as controls on interpretation.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

althiqah

Publisher

Subject

Religion Social Sciences

Description

Al-THIQAH : Jurnal Ilmu Keislaman published by Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ushuluddin Bangkalan. This journal contains many variants of Islamic studies, among others: Islamic education, Ushuluddin, the Shariah, Islamic thought, economics, and other Islamic studies. This journal is published twice a year in ...